We tested the Oura Ring 5 vs Apple Watch vs Garmin Index Sleep Monitor for 6 months — here's the best Black Friday buy

Composite image showing the Oura Ring 5, Apple Watch, and Garmin Index Sleep Monitor being rested for review
(Image credit: Future/Oura)
0

I've been wearing the Oura Ring 5, now $299 (was $399) at Amazon, for five months, and it's even helped me go from six to seven hours of sleep a night. But is this screenless sleep tracker worth the investment over the Apple Watch 12 or Garmin Index Sleep Monitor?

Apple, Garmin, and Oura all appear in our guide to this year's best sleep trackers with the Oura Ring taking the top spot. In this sleep tracker triple header, I'm exploring the key differences between the Oura Ring 5 vs the Apple Watch vs the Garmin Index Sleep Monitor to help you decide which wearable to is worth your money in the Black Friday sales.

And if you're upgrading other aspects of your sleep set up too, then take a look at our guide to this year's best Black Friday mattress deals.

Oura Ring 5 vs Apple Watch vs Garmin: Price & deals

  • The Oura Ring 5 is $100 off for Black Friday: $299 (was $399)
  • The Apple Watch 12 is on sale for $329.99 (was $xxx)
  • The Garmin Index Sleep Monitor costs $169.99, but previous deals have dropped it to $130.50

At MSRP, the Oura Ring 5 starts at $399 and goes up to $499, depending what shade (or "finish") you choose. For example, a silver Oura Ring 5 is $399, while a gold Oura Ring 5 is $499.

Until now, you'd have to pay full price for this state-of-the-art tracker. But thanks to the money-saving magic of Black Friday, the Oura Ring 5 has received its first ever price drop: a $100 discount, no less. This means you can buy an Oura Ring 5 from $299 (was $399) at Amazon.

a photo of the sleep tracking on the Apple Watch Ultra

(Image credit: Future)

The 5 isn't the only Oura Ring discounted right now — the older Oura Ring 4 is now from just $249.99 (was $349.99) at Amazon. You can read my Oura Ring 5 vs Oura Ring 4 comparison guide to see if it's worth downgrading to save money.

But before you buy the new-and-improved Oura Ring 5, there are some hidden costs to consider. First, you need a sizing kit.

This is completely free direct from Oura, or $10 at Amazon. Second, the monthly subscription. Yes, you need to pay a $5.99 membership fee every month to use Oura's sleep tracking (the first month is free).

On the flip side, the Apple Watch and the Garmin Index Sleep Monitor require no subscription fees. The Garmin Index Sleep Monitor is the cheapest of the bunch, at $169.99 at Amazon.

I've also spotted deals during sale events, such as when it was reduced to $130.50 during the Amazon Prime Day sales. I'll be watching for further discounts.

The most recent Apple Watch model, the Apple Watch 12 is now $329.99 (was $399.99) at Amazon, and you can catch plenty of cheaper Apple Watch deals on previous models.

Oura Ring 5
Oura Ring 5: was $399 now $299 at Amazon

This is the first time we've seen a discount on the Oura Ring 5 and it's a big one, with prices starting at just $299 — a 25% discount. With $100 off across the collection, premium finishes such as gold are now $399 (was $499). You need to pay a monthly $5.99 subscription to use Oura but the first month is free.

Apple Watch 12
Apple Watch 12: was $399 now $329 at Amazon

The latest Apple Watch was released just a few weeks ago, so this Black Friday sale is yur first chance to save. Prices start at $329 (was $399) for the smaller design, with the larger face setting you back $379 (was $448).

Garmin Index Sleep Monitor
Garmin Index Sleep Monitor: $169.99 at Amazon

At $169.99, the Garmin Index Sleep Monitor is the most affordable of the three and you don't need a subscription, either. However, we're still hoping to see a price drop before Black Friday, as it dropped to $130.50 in the Prime Day sales.

Design and sleep comfort

  • Oura Ring 5 is a screenless smart ring, in sizes to fit most fingers
  • Apple Watch comes in various models, with some slimmer than others
  • The screen-free Index Sleep Monitor is an armband with two sizes

The Oura Ring 5 holds the title of the "world's smallest smart ring", with a focus on a slim design and lightweight barely-there feel.

After wearing the Oura Ring 5 for five months, I must say that it lives up to its title. Not once have I ever felt any discomfort from wearing the ring, with its sleep design never interfering with my sleep. Thanks to the sizing kit, it fits like a glove, too.

A woman's hand models the Oura Ring 5 before a freshly-made hotel bed.

(Image credit: Future)

The Oura Ring 5's fit was a breath of fresh air compared to the Apple Watch Ultra that I wore to bed for a few months before I obtained the Oura Ring 5. Granted, the Apple Watch Ultra is a lot bigger and bulkier than the newer Apple Watch models, such as the Apple Watch 12.

But all Apple Watches are exactly that: watches. I find any wristwatch uncomfortable to wear in bed, particularly smartwatches with heavy screens and tight straps (you need plenty of skin contact for tracking accuracy). But that's a personal preference and if you don't mind something bulky on your wrist in bed, you might sleep happily in the Apple Watch 12.

As for the Garmin, the lead tester in our Garmin Index Sleep Monitor review found the armband design to be surprisingly comfortable and lightweight. The band is available in two sizes (S-M and L-XL), and its screen-free design means it isn't weighed down by heavy monitors.

Sleep tracking

  • Oura's sleep tracking is renowned for accuracy and unique features
  • Apple boasts sleep apnea detection, but its sleep metrics aren't as advanced
  • Garmin offers accurate sleep metrics that are geared more towards recovery

When it comes down to it, the Oura, Apple, and Garmin sleep trackers share a lot of core sleep tracking features. For example, not only do all three tell you how long you slept, but also how much of that sleep duration was spent in deep sleep, REM sleep, and core sleep (along with how long your night-time awakenings last). They also all provide sleep scores, which measure your overall sleep quality on a scale of 1 to 100.

You can find the key sleep metrics in the Oura app, Garmin Connect app, and the Apple Health app respectively. For the screenless Oura and Garmin, this is the only way to view your sleep data. But you get immediate feedback from your Apple Watch via the Vitals app on the monitor.

The Oura Ring 5 is designed to provide more sleep tracking accuracy than the Oura Ring 4, with a build that improves the sensors' contact with skin and 12% more accuracy in its overnight Heart Rate Variability (HRV) monitoring.

Our sleep tech tester testing the Garmin Index Sleep Monitor

(Image credit: Future)

I've found the Oura Ring one of the most dependable consumer sleep trackers on the market. It's especially good at knowing when you're asleep vs awake; studies show up to 96% accuracy when compared to clinical polysomnography (PSG).

I can see the Oura Ring 5's accuracy first hand. When I wore the Oura Ring 5 and the Apple Watch (Ultra) at the same time, I felt the Oura Ring's data reflected how I felt in the morning more accurately than the Apple Watch. For instance, my Apple Watch sleep scores are always much higher than my Oura Ring — despite regularly getting under seven hours of sleep.

That said, the Apple Watch does provide a sleep apnea detection tool (available on the Apple Watch Series 10 and up), which analyzes your breathing patterns to detect disturbances that might signal sleep apnea.

Close-up of the Apple Watch 12 on a user's wrist with the new dynamic Readiness Score shown

(Image credit: Tom's Guide)

Meanwhile, the Garmin Index Sleep Monitor provides a readiness score, which tells you how prepared your body is to handle daily activities (such as workouts) based on your sleep data.

Our lead tester for the Garmin Index Sleep Monitor, Eve Davies, said that the Garmin is "more focused on overnight breathing rates, oxygen levels and respiration rates — is essentially more ‘nerdy’ and geared towards athletic recovery". For data lovers, there's a lot to unpack.

It's also worth mentioning that the Oura Ring 5's sleep latency metric is missing from the Apple Watch and Index Sleep Monitor. And its unique circadian scoring, which uses sleep data over time to identify your sleep chronotype, can help you identify how well your sleep routine aligns with your circadian rhythm.

Battery life

  • The Oura Ring 5's battery lasts up to nine days, depending on size
  • Apple Watch battery life varies by model, but Series 12 lasts up to a day
  • Depending on your time asleep, the Garmin can last eight nights

The Oura Ring 5 being charged.

(Image credit: Future)

The Oura Ring 5 is designed to provide around six to nine days of battery life on a single charge. A full charge (from zero to 100) is said to take up to 80 minutes, though I find it charges much faster than this.

That said, I've never found that my ring's battery life has lasted nine days (or even a full week), but this may be due to the fact that I wear a size 7 — the smaller sizes have a shorter battery life.

However, the lifespan of an Oura Ring is that of a giant tortoise when compared with the Apple Watch. The Apple Watch requires daily charging, with the latest 12th Generation's battery life lasting no longer than 24 hours.

The Garmin has quite a lengthy battery life, lasting up to eight nights (however, this can depend on your sleep duration). However, you also wear it less than the Oura Ring 5 or Apple Watch — if you strapped it to yourself all day, expect that battery life to go right down.

Oura Ring 5 vs Apple Watch vs Garmin: Which should you buy?

Buy the Oura Ring 5 sleep tracker if...

✅ You want in-depth sleep tracking: The Oura Ring 5's accuracy is renowned, while its unique sleep features (such as its Body Clock feature) sets it apart.

✅ You value optimal sleep comfort: Thanks to a custom fit and a sleek, lightweight build, the Oura Ring 5 is perfect for a barely-there feel.

✅ You don't own an iPhone: You need an iPhone to set up your Apple Watch, so consider the Oura Ring 5 if you're an Android user.

Choose the Apple Watch 12 if...

✅ You don't want to pay monthly fees: The Apple Watch has no hidden subscription costs.

✅ You want immediate feedback: With a screen to view your metrics, the Apple Watch is the only option that doesn't require fiddling about with an app.

✅ You want more versatility: There's a lot more to the Apple Watch than sleep tracking, including highly-rated fitness tracking, and there are plenty of models to suit your requirements.

Choose the Garmin Index Sleep Monitor if...

✅ You want the most budget-friendly tracker: The Garmin Index Sleep Monitor is never sold over $170, and you can reliably find it on sale during holiday seasons.

✅ You just want a sleep tracker: While the Oura Ring 5 and Apple Watch put a lot of energy into fitness and health tracking, the Garmin Index Sleep Monitor is strictly for sleep tracking.

✅ You want a long battery life: The Garmin Index Sleep Monitor can last up to eight nights on a single charge.


Google News

Follow Tom's Guide on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our up-to-date news, analysis, and reviews in your feeds.


Frances Daniels
Senior Sleep Staff Writer

Frances Daniels is a PPA-accredited journalist and Sleep Staff Writer at Tom's Guide with an MA in Magazine Journalism from Cardiff University. Her role includes covering mattress and sleep news and writing sleep product reviews and buyer's guides, including our Best Hybrid Mattress 2025 guide. She is interested in the relationship between sleep and health, interviewing an array of experts to create in-depth articles about topics such as nutrition, sleep disorders, sleep hygiene, and mattress care. She is also our specialist on mattress toppers — producing bed topper reviews and taking care of our Best Mattress Toppers 2025 guide — and leads content relating to fiberglass-free beds for a non-toxic sleep. Outside of Tom's Guide, she has written for Ideal Home and Marie Claire.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.