5 signs you should be sleeping on a soft mattress, not a medium-firm bed

A man with dark hair sleeps on his side on a soft mattress covered by a white comforter
(Image credit: Getty)

A mattress that's too firm for your body type and the position you sleep in can lead to restless nights and longterm aches and pains. It can be difficult to decipher what mattress firmness is for you, but if you currently own a medium-firm mattress and identify with any of the signs in this article, it could be time to switch to a soft mattress.

Soft mattresses can be a good match for sleepers who suffer from joint or hip pain. Our guide to this year's best mattresses for all sleepers features a number of soft mattresses that deliver a plush, sink-in feel. Soft mostly mattresses tend to suit people with a lightweight body, plus side sleepers needing the right balance of pressure relief and comfort. 

Here we run through five signs that you should be sleeping on a soft mattress, not a medium-firm. And if decide that you need to buy a mattress after all, there are plenty of good mattress sales around right now with up to 55% off. 

What is a soft mattress?

A soft mattress is a bed with a firmness rating of between 3 to 6 (out of 10) on the firmness scale. Sometimes they can be branded as Plush or Luxury Plush but soft mattresses are a popular choice for lightweight sleepers or those who prefer to sleep on their side.

Don’t think because a mattress is soft that it won’t offer enough support. Some of the best memory foam mattresses have a soft rating and are designed with advanced foams that contour your body shape to ensure proper spinal alignment. 

This tailored support also makes soft mattresses suitable for anyone suffering from hip and joint pain because the soft cushioning combined with the pressure-relieving properties of a soft surface can alleviate pain and lead to a better sleep experience. 

5 signs you should be sleeping on a soft mattress, not a medium-firm

1. You experience joint pain

A woman in a brown t-shirt massages her painful lower back in bed

(Image credit: Getty)

If you frequently wake up with pain in your hips, shoulders or knees then you may find that a soft mattress is a better choice for you. Soft mattresses can offer more contouring and cushioning than medium-firm mattresses, which can reduce pressure points in these three key areas. 

You may find that some of the best hybrid mattresses are a good fit as these often offer a soft, plush comfort layer with the responsiveness of springs which bring together that perfect balance of comfort and support. 

2. You have a lighter body weight

If you have a lower body weight then you may find that a medium-firm mattress doesn’t give you the right amount of pressure relief. Lighter individuals don’t put as much pressure on their mattress surface as those with a heavier weight body.

This means that a medium-firm or firm mattress may not conform to their body shape in the same way. Additional pressure is then put on areas like the shoulders, knees and hips causing pain and discomfort. 

A softer mattress will cradle these pressure points by distributing your body weight more evenly. So if you weigh less than 130lbs, it’s worth looking at a soft mattress to achieve optimum comfort. 

3. You sleep on your side

Soft mattresses can cradle curves and leave shoulders and hips feeling supported which makes them a great choice for side sleepers. One of the main problems side sleepers face is putting pressure on their joints as their weight pushes down on these areas when lying on your side. 

A woman with dark curly hair sleeps on her side in a pink nightdress

(Image credit: Getty Images)

A softer mattress will allow these points to sink in to the mattress all whilst keeping the spine perfectly aligned and leaving you waking up in the morning ache-free. Side sleepers may also find that the squishy, plush comfort of a soft mattress will lead them falling to sleep faster as they are instantly able to achieve the perfect level of comfort. 

4. You love a plush feel

Let’s face it, when we think about our ideal bed not many of us think about flopping down on a medium-firm or firm mattress with no sink-in softness. Instead we conjure up the image of peeling back the sheets and crawling in to a soft, cozy mattress that contours our body to perfection. 

Personal preference has a huge part of play when it comes to choosing your mattress. What you may find too soft or too firm will be absolutely perfect for someone else. If you currently have a medium-firm mattress and you’re finding it a little too firm then why not make a change and invest in a new soft mattress? 

If you’re unsure whether a soft mattress really will work for you, you could experiment with one of the best mattress toppers first to suss out whether you actually like the soft feel and whether it suits your sleeping style.  

5. You wake up with numbness or tingling

If your mattress is too firm for you then one of the major signs you’ll notice along with any joint pain is numbness or tingling when you wake. This is because your mattress and the way you’re lying on it could be restricting blood flow to certain parts of the body such as your arms, hands or feet. 

A softer mattress will reduce that pressure and allow for better circulation. If you’re waking with numbness or tingling then it’s best to address the issue sooner or later, not only is it uncomfortable but it can be bad for your overall circulation and is a sign that you definitely shouldn’t ignore. 

The top three soft mattress on sale today

1.Saatva Classic:Was from $1,395$1,195 at Saatva

1.Saatva Classic: Was from $1,395 $1,195 at Saatva
The Saatva Classic comes in two heights and three firmness options, including Plush Soft. Our Saatva Classic mattress review says that the pressure relief on this mattress is great and it’s the ideal choice for any sleeper with joint pain. Saatva currently have savings of up to $300 on this mattress bringing the price of a queen Saatva Classic down to just $1,795 (was $2,095). You also benefit from a 365-night home trial, a lifetime warranty and free white glove delivery.

2. Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid:Was from $665 $498.80 at Brooklyn Bedding

2. Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid: Was from $665 $498.80 at Brooklyn Bedding 
Brooklyn Bedding's Signature Hybrid mattress comes in soft, medium or firm tension and is constructed using a combination of Supreme Response Comfort Foam, Variflex Transition Foam and 8” Individually Encased Coils. You can buy it in wide range of sizes, including RV mattress sizes. Brooklyn Bedding often run sales so you’ll never pay full MSRP for one of their beds. Right now you can save 25% on a queen Signature Hybrid, down to $999. The mattress also comes with a 120-night trial and a 10-year warranty. 

3. The Winkbed:Was from $1,149$849 at WinkBeds

3. The Winkbed: Was from $1,149 $849 at WinkBeds
Like the Saatva Classic, The Winkbed mattress offers range of firmness options including a softer tension which sits at around 4.5 out of 10 for firmness. This mattress offers exceptional support for side sleepers who are seeking some cushioning comfort. Our review of The WinkBed says that offers sturdy zoned support for the spine. There are some great deals available at the moment with a queen Winkbed coming in at $1,499 (was $1,799). There is also a 120-night sleep trial, lifetime warranty and free shipping and returns. 

Looking for more deals? You can find the best deals year round with our mattress coupon codes where you'll find offers for everything from bedding to pillows and mattresses to give your bed the refresh it deserves.

Rachael Penn
Contributor

Rachael is a freelance journalist based in South Wales who writes about lifestyle, travel, home and technology. She also reviews a variety of products for various publications including Tom’s Guide, CreativeBloq, IdealHome and Woman&Home. When she’s not writing and reviewing products she can be found walking her Sealyham and West Highland terrier dogs or catching up on some cringe-worthy reality tv. 

Read more
Helix midnight elite mattress
I test mattresses for a living — here’s what soft mattresses do for side sleepers
Two women sit on the Helix Midnight Elite mattress as they look for the right mattress for their sleep position, a Tom's Guide Sleep Awareness Week deals graphic (right)
5 signs your mattresses no longer suits your sleep position — and what to pick instead
The Saatva Classic mattress photographed from up high to show the lumbar support section
Do medium-firm mattresses suit all sleepers? How to tell if you need a firmer or softer bed
A hand presses into the surface of the Plank Firm, a firm memory foam mattress (left) and a hand presses into the surface of the Zinus Mattress, a soft memory foam mattress (right)
I’ve slept on firm and soft memory foam mattresses — here’s which one you should buy
A woman wearing green tshirt sitting in bed with her bed tilted and her hand on her neck.
I test mattresses for a living — here's what a firm mattress does for side sleepers
A woman with brown hair lies on her stomach on top of a mattress for front sleepers that she has chosen to buy
How to choose a mattress for your sleep position
Latest in Mattresses
Attractive heavy woman sitting on a bed smiling at the camera
Your mattress' weight limit might be the reason you can't sleep — here's why
Navy and white Bear Elite Hybrid mattress in bedroom with wooden floor, black and beige rug, grey chair and black bedside tables
Hot sleeper? Get up to 35% off these cooling mattresses this weekend
A woman lying on her back on the Casper The One mattress
The Casper mattress I'd buy is on sale today — save 20% on the Casper The One
A man in a grey t shirt sits on the edge of his mattress while clutching his lower back after waking up with back and shoulder pain
3 tell-tale signs you’ve aged out of your current mattress
A man in blue pyjamas laying on his side on Sleep Number Climate360 smart mattress
What is the Sleep Number Climate360 smart bed and should you buy it?
A closeup of the foot of the Helix Midnight Luxe mattress, a Tom's Guide price drop deals graphic (left)
3 queen hybrid mattresses from just $424 to shop this weekend
Latest in Features
2025 Mini Cooper Countryman SE All4 review.
I drove the Mini Cooper Countryman EV for a week — here’s my pros and cons
Troubadour Apex 3.0 Backpack
I tested this laptop backpack for 6 months — and it’s one of the best purchases I’ve ever made
a person with muscular calves running
Physio says runners need these 3 calf strength variations in their training — here’s why I’m finally listening
Obscura VPN website landing page
Obscura VPN wants to be the "best darn VPN out there" – can it?
Galaxy S25 Ultra next to macro shot of flower
I test camera phones for a living — here's 3 tips for taking great macro shots
Nokia 3210
Feature phones are now having a 'renaissance' — here's why