Nothing's CMF Phone 1 could be the cheap Android phone of the year — here's why

CMF Phone 1
(Image credit: Future)

One of the biggest questions everyone needs to answer when buying a new phone is which color to pick. I know I spend a lot of time debating on which one I’d choose, but when I do make a decision, I realize I’ve wasted time trying to convince myself of going naked because I always end up getting a wallet case.

With the CMF Phone 1 by Nothing, it puts phone designs back into the conversation because of how it features one that lets you change its back cover. But it doesn’t end at just choosing a color for the phone since there are more add-on accessories to personalize the Android phone.

Everything about it reminds me of the Moto X, which gave people an unprecedented level of customizing the design — down to the color of the casing and its accents. But that implementation still forced users to stick with one color, whereas Nothing gives you more control of it with the CMF Phone 1.

And best of all, it costs less than $250 and is a strong contender in our best cheap phones guide. We really need more phones like it.

Settling is not an option anymore

CMF Phone 1

(Image credit: Future)

Whenever I come across phones under the $500 threshold, they’re rarely offered in multiple color options — and color variety is rarely a luxury for some of the best phones under $300. Typically I expect two color options, black and white, but what’s special about the CMF Phone 1 by Nothing is that you don’t have to settle on just one.

When I first took it out of the box, the first thing I realized was how it kept to a mostly plastic construction. It’s far from the glass meets metal constructions we see in most of the best phones today, but it’s befitting for its price point. Yet, there’s something special here because I’m able to swap out the color for another.

Instead of settling for the boring black casing, I ended up replacing it with the light green one. But I didn’t stop there because I replaced its usual silver colored screws for black ones, as well as replacing the light green corner cover to an orange one. This kind of customization is rare among phones today, but Nothing deserves credit for making it happen on a budget phone.

It’s still water-resistant to an extent

CMF Phone 1

(Image credit: Future)

Since the casing is held together by screws, one of my big concerns is that it wouldn’t be able to deal with getting wet. I’m not talking about plunging into a pool with the phone in hand, but rather, just out for a stroll with it lightly drizzling outside. I’m not alone about this one, especially when other people are genuinely interested in this ‘compromise.’

Thankfully, the CMF Phone 1 features an IP52 rating, and while it’s nowhere to the degree that flagship phones get, it’s better than none at all. Meaning, it's safeguarded against water splashes less than 15 degree from vertical. And while it’s technically not constructed to be dust tight, it’s designed to keep most of it out.

Considering that I’m unlikely to take photos or video underwater, I’m perfectly willing to settle with an IP52 construction — especially if it means I can easily customize the design.

A thoughtfully designed cheap phone

CMF Phone 1

(Image credit: Future)

I still cannot stress that you’re getting a customizable design with a phone that costs less than the majority of phones out there. Small details like the corner cover on the back show how it’s been thoughtfully designed to give off that charm factor that few phones offer.

I only need to walk outside onto the busy streets of New York City to see how ubiquitous iPhones and Samsung Galaxy phones have become. The only time my interest is piqued is whenever I see an oddball, like a Pixel or some kind of foldable phone.

The CMF Phone 1 has a lot going for it when it comes to phone designs. It’s a refreshing change that proves to me that attractive designs can come in all sorts of packages. What’s even more compelling here is how a customizable design such as this comes in at $239, excluding the cost of buying other colored cases and accessories. I’m just hopeful that it can convince me in other areas, like its camera performance and battery life, since those are two critical areas that can make or break a phone.

More from Tom's Guide

John Velasco
Senior Channel Editor for Phones

John’s a senior editor covering phones for Tom’s Guide. He’s no stranger in this area having covered mobile phones and gadgets since 2008 when he started his career. On top of his editor duties, he’s a seasoned videographer being in front and behind the camera producing YouTube videos. Previously, he held editor roles with PhoneArena, Android Authority, Digital Trends, and SPY. Outside of tech, he enjoys producing mini documentaries and fun social clips for small businesses, enjoying the beach life at the Jersey Shore, and recently becoming a first time homeowner.

Read more
Google Pixel 9a render
Google Pixel 9a needs to be more like the Nothing Phone 3a — here’s how
Nothing Phone 3a in hand
Nothing Phone 3a review: Redefining value
Nothing Phone 3a Pro review photos.
Nothing Phone 3a Pro review: Apple and Google should be worried
Google Pixel 9a hands-on.
Google Pixel 9a hands-on: This cheap phone just surpassed the iPhone 16e
close up on Moto G 2025 cameras
I review phones for a living — and this is the budget phone I recommend to friends and family
OnePlus 13R camera array close-up
OnePlus 13R is proof you never need to spend big on a flagship again — here's why
Latest in Phones
New emojis with iOS 18.4 beta release.
iOS 18.4 beta brings 8 new emoji to your iPhone — here's all the new options
Galaxy S25 Plus held in the hand.
Samsung could delay One UI 7’s release in the US — here’s what we know
Apple iPhone 16 & 16 Plus hands-on.
iPhone 17 just tipped for this long overdue Pro feature in new report
Android 16 screen-off fingerprint unlock in Settings menu
Android 16's latest beta lets all Pixel users unlock their phone more easily — here’s how
Foldable iPhone concept image
Apple's foldable 'iPhone Flip' tipped for release in 2026 with a familiar design and iPhone 17 Air features
Galaxy S25 Ultra Now brief
Samsung’s Personal Data Engine is a big addition to the Galaxy S25 — here’s why
Latest in Features
A hand feels the temperature regulation of the SPRINGSPIRIT Dual Layer Mattress Topper.
What is a bamboo mattress topper and should you buy one?
2025 Mini Cooper Countryman SE All4 review.
I drove the Mini Cooper Countryman EV for a week — here’s my pros and cons
Troubadour Apex 3.0 Backpack
I tested this laptop backpack for 6 months — and it’s one of the best purchases I’ve ever made
a person with muscular calves running
Physio says runners need these 3 calf strength variations in their training — here’s why I’m finally listening
Obscura VPN website landing page
Obscura VPN wants to be the "best darn VPN out there" – can it?
Galaxy S25 Ultra next to macro shot of flower
I test camera phones for a living — here's 3 tips for taking great macro shots
  • CicoB
    Nothing's cmf phone 1 was great idea never brought to the finish line. People like myself bought it exactly for the customizing possibilities, except that there aren't none. No parts for sale anywhere, no customer support to be of any usefulness and tech support? Nothing.
    Yes it was a great concept and I fell for it.
    Reply