Samsung's ridiculous S Pen saga continues — users complain magnetic accessories cause issues

Galaxy S25 Ultra display showing home screen and S Pen
(Image credit: Tom's Guide)

Anyone looking for a new case for their Galaxy S25 Ultra should take note, the S Pen does not like magnetic cases, and it hasn't for a long time.

There's been a lot of comments in recent months about the Galaxy S25 Ultra and Samsung's removal of the S Pen's Bluetooth features. However, it seems the S25 Ultra's S Pen does share at least one thing with the Galaxy S24 Ultra's pen, and it's not good.

Recently, several reports arose on Reddit regarding magnetic cases and accessories affecting the Galaxy S24 Ultra's Pen, and it seems that the Galaxy S25 Ultra has the same issue, at least according to Android Central.

According to the site, when connecting magnetic accessories or cases to the Galaxy S25 Ultra, a popup will appear that claims, “Magnetic accessories can interfere with your S Pen: The magnets in accessories can interfere with the signals your S Pen sends to your phone. They may cause your S Pen to not write correctly or cause Air commands to occur unintentionally.”

Magnetic warning on Galaxy S25 Ultra

(Image credit: Android Central)

The idea of the magnets affecting the pen seems odd, but there will likely be several factors at play. For instance, Android Central's Andrew Myrick reported separately the warning didn't appear when he used a MagSafe adapter with a Samsung Silicone case.

That would indicate that one of the possible factors is the distance between the S Pen and the magnet. Other factors are likely the strength and size of the magnet, and how deep it is kept inside the case.

It's also worth noting that this isn't a new problem. Samsung devices have had the same issues since the Galaxy Note 8. In a post from 2020, Samsung states that S Pen actions may not work properly when using a magnetic cover. This is especially prevalent around specific areas affected by magnetic force like the front camera.

In a post from 2020, Samsung states that S Pen actions may not work properly when using a magnetic cover.

Samsung went on to recommend that, on the Note 8, users should hold the S Pen upright and use more force when this issue occurs. This isn't something we'd recommend ourselves nor should it even be necessary half-a-decade later in 2025.

Unfortunately, there aren't any real solutions for this, outside of not using magnetic cases at all. But since most of the best Galaxy S25 Ultra cases make use of MagSafe features, this seems like an additional feature tax on the consumer. Especially since owning a case is still one of the best ways to protect your new phone.

More from Tom's Guide

Josh Render
Staff Writer

Josh is a staff writer for Tom's Guide and is based in the UK. He has worked for several publications but now works primarily on mobile phones. Outside of phones, he has a passion for video games, novels, and Warhammer. 

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.

Read more
Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra
The Samsung Galaxy S25 supports Qi2 charging — but there's a big catch
samsung galaxy s25 ultra with qi-enabled magnetic case
Samsung Galaxy S25 case leak hints at a major upgrade
Galaxy S25 Ultra display showing home screen and S Pen
Galaxy S25 Ultra confusion — Samsung now says you can buy Bluetooth S Pen separately
Galaxy s25 Ultra concept design by Technizo Concept on YouTube
Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra S Pen could get downgraded — what we know
Using the stylus on a Galaxy S25 Ultra
The Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra S Pen should be sold separately — here’s why
Galaxy S25 Ultra display showing home screen and S Pen
Samsung has started selling Galaxy S25 Ultra S Pen replacements — here's what they cost
Latest in Android Phones
Google Pixel 9a render
Google Pixel 9a will have to fix one crucial thing to hold off its low-cost rivals
Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge back
Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge price comes into focus with latest leak
Google Pixel 5 review
Google Pixel 10 lineup leaked in new renderings — here's what they look like
Galaxy Z Fold 6 shown in hand
Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 6 just got these major upgrades with One UI 7
Pixel 9a vs Pixel 8a
Google Pixel 9a vs. Pixel 8a: Biggest changes to expect
Honor Magic V teaser image
Watch out, Galaxy Z Fold 7 — Honor Magic V4 leak just revealed a killer foldable
Latest in News
Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge back
Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge price comes into focus with latest leak
Apple iPhone 16 Plus Review.
Apple just released an emergency security update for a flaw used in an ‘extremely sophisticated attack’ — update your devices right now
NYTimes Connections
NYT Connections today hints and answers — Wednesday, March 12 (#640)
Jean Smart as Deborah Vance and Hannah Einbinder as Ava Daniels in Hacks
Max reveals 'Hacks' season 4 release date and trailer — here's when it's coming
Google Pixel 5 review
Google Pixel 10 lineup leaked in new renderings — here's what they look like
A person trying to set up a new Wi-Fi router
Thousands of TP-Link routers have been infected by a botnet to spread malware