I'm a true crime TV nut — but this is now officially overkill

Colin Firth and the cast of The Staircase
(Image credit: HBO Max)

I'm a true crime nut, so this is almost painful to say: There's too much true crime on TV right now.

The other day, after finishing up Netflix's chilling doc Our Father, I realized I'm in the middle of actively watching six true crime series: HBO Max's The Staircase; Netflix's Conversations With a Killer: The John Wayne Gacy Tapes; Apple TV Plus' WeCrashed; and Hulu's Candy, The Girl From Plainville and Under the Banner of Heaven.

I have 10 more saved on various watch lists, including We Own This City, Dr. Death, The Big Conn, and Jimmy Savile: A British Horror Story. Not to mention the unfinished shows languishing in my queue (I swear I'll get back to you, Landscapers, Lady and the Dale, and The Sons of Sam ... uh, some day).

And every week brings even more new true crime documentaries and dramas. The true crime bonanza has no end in sight. And frankly, even for this fanatic, it's exhausting.

It's all streaming's fault

True crime has been around for decades. Unsolved Mysteries riveted viewers in the '80s and continues to do so on Netflix now as one of the best shows on Netflix. I watched one of the forebears of modern true crime docu-series, The Staircase, back in 2004 when it first aired on the Sundance Channel. 

So, the popularity of true crime isn't new. But the genre truly exploded thanks to cultural sensations like the podcast Serial, Making a Murderer and The Jinx. After that, streaming services swarmed true crime like a gold rush. Established platforms like Netflix and Hulu were already veterans of this game, but new players like HBO Max and Peacock have taken it to a new level. 

And then came the pandemic. Everybody went into lockdown, unable to go to movie theaters, concerts and Broadway musicals. Instead, they stayed home and watched television. It's not a surprise that the first big quarantine hit was a true crime series, Netflix's Tiger King. 

Tiger King on Netflix

(Image credit: Netflix)

In the last two years, we've been hit with wave after wave — not just of COVID-19, but streaming true crime documentaries and dramas. Tiger King was followed by the NXIVM exposé The Vow, I'll Be Gone in the Dark, scammer series McMillions, American Murder: The Family Next Door and the divorce-gone-very-wrong drama Dirty John: The Betty Broderick Story, among many others. 

Last year saw major true crime releases like Allen v. Farrow, The Investigation, Dopesick and LuLaRich. And as a parody of true crime podcasts, Only Murders in the Building is genre-adjacent. 

Streaming's embrace of true crime is understandable. One, it's popular and tends to generate a lot of social media buzz. Services want to attract and retain subscribers. Netflix might be experiencing a downturn now, but in spring 2020, everybody was talking about and watching Tiger King. 

Second, documentaries are generally cheaper to make than scripted series and movies. With Netflix, and likely other streamers, clamping down on budgets, we might get even more docs than ever before. 

I need a true crime break

Poster art for The Girl From Plainville featuring Elle Fanning

(Image credit: Hulu)

You know how there are all those stories about how many lottery winners suffers breakdowns and wind up losing their fortunes? That's how I feel as a true crime aficionado now. 

Right now, I'm fumbling with my true crime riches. I'm three episodes behind on The Staircase and just halfway through The Girl From Plainville and WeCrashed. I'm only on episode 2 of both Under the Banner of Heaven and Candy. As I mentioned before, there are a lot more that I haven't even begun or paused indefinitely. New stuff is constantly premiering, like next week's Peacock's Sins of the Amish on Peacock and Hulu's Keeper of the Ashes: The Oklahoma Girl Scout Murders. I haven't contemplated subscribing to Discovery Plus; I might never see the light of day again.

There must be a German word for this feeling of wanting something, yet also being completely overwhelmed by it. 

So, maybe it's time for a break — a summer vacation from true crime. All the murders, scams, heists and drug deals can wait. They've already happened, so no spoilers. And as the cliché goes, absence makes the heart grow fonder. 

Read next: The John Wayne Gacy Tapes just got a second wind on Netflix, and has been climbing the top 10

TOPICS
Kelly Woo
Streaming Editor

Kelly is the managing editor of streaming for Tom’s Guide, so basically, she watches TV for a living. Previously, she was a freelance entertainment writer for Yahoo, Vulture, TV Guide and other outlets. When she’s not watching TV and movies for work, she’s watching them for fun, seeing live music, writing songs, knitting and gardening.

Read more
Edward Galland, David Kellman, and Robert Shafran in Three Identical Strangers
5 most harrowing documentary thrillers I've ever seen
Michael C. Hall as Dexter Morgan in Dexter TV show (2006)
5 best shows like 'Dexter' to stream after 'Original Sin' finale
Hiroyuki Sanada in Shogun, Gary Oldman in Slow Horses and Eddie Redmayne in The Day of the Jackal
I've streamed 53 shows in 2024 — here's the 7 best and 7 worst
"Capturing the Killer Nurse" on Netflix
33 best Netflix documentaries to watch right now
Belle Gibson (Kaitlyn Dever) in Netflix's "Apple Cider Vinegar"
5 best shows like 'Apple Cider Vinegar' to stream next
A TV with the Netflix logo sits behind a hand holding a remote
I might finally cancel Netflix this year — here's why
Latest in Streaming
Cover of Robbie Williams as a CGI monkey in "Better Man"
This music biopic I missed from 2024 is finally coming to streaming
Kate Hudson as Isla Gordon in "Running Point" now streaming on Netflix
Netflix top 10 shows — here’s the 3 worth watching right now
Penn Badgley as Joe Goldberg in episode 502 of You
New ‘You’ season 5 trailer teases Netflix show’s killer final season
Christopher Briney as Conrad and Lola Tung as Belly in The Summer I Turned Pretty
Prime Video top 10 shows — here’s the 3 worth watching right now
Google Chromecast in TV
Chromecast fail — users across the world are saying that their Chromecasts are not working
Juana Acosta as Bárbara Hidalgo in "Medusa" now streaming on Netflix
Netflix just got a new dramatic thriller show that’s already crashed the top 10
Latest in Opinion
(From L to R) Michelle Rodriguez as Holga the Barbarian, Chris Pine as Edgin Darvis, Justice Smith as Simon the Sorcerer, and Sophia Lillis as Doric next to a Gelatinous Cube
'Dungeons and Dragons: Honor Among Thieves' just crashed Netflix's top 10 movies — and it's a hilarious, heartfelt adventure
An iPad mini 7 on a desk with a finger resting over its power button with Touch ID
I spent two weeks with the iPad mini 7 and it reignited my love for smaller tablets
A Samsung TV box on the floor of a Walmart. It is strapped shut and ready to be moved.
Here's why you should never throw out the box that came with your TV
Hugh Grant in "Heretic"
Hugh Grant’s terrifying villain turn just landed on Max — and it’s got 91% on Rotten Tomatoes
Samsung Display Bezel-less tile concept at MWC 2025
Bezel-less tile OLED TVs could be the future of large-screen displays
Patricia Arquette as Harmony Cobel in Severance
'Severance' season 2 just dropped the biggest bombshell of the series so far