I’d buy an Xbox Series S tomorrow — with this one big change

Xbox Series S review
(Image credit: Tom's Guide)

Update: Microsoft might be about to fix the Xbox Series S's biggest problems, and let you convert game discs into digital downloads

There’s no shortage of consoles living under my TV, some of which get more use than others. The PS5 gets turned on daily – even if it’s more for backwards compatible PS4 multiplayer gaming with my girlfriend – and the Nintendo Switch gets regular use too. Finally, there’s an Xbox One S, which gets occasional use to check out the latest Game Pass freebies.

Microsoft’s machine is the longest serving of these, and it’s been a trusty companion that is definitely due an upgrade. But with the PS5 (a necessity for multiplayer with my closest friends) I can’t really justify the expense of an Xbox Series X – there are, after all, only so many hours in a day for gaming, much as we’d all wish it wasn’t so. 

At this point, you can practically hear the Xbox Series S doing an elaborate stage cough. And yes, the truth is that I’d probably own Microsoft’s $299 console right now if it weren’t for that one, significant drawback: I can’t ditch the disk drive.

I’m aware of the arguments that I’m locked in the past — and the big stack of CD albums next to my desk definitely backs this up — but for me, the lack of disk drive on the Series S is non negotiable. In fact, in my oddly specific use case, it would take away much of the cost savings of the Series S in the first place. 

I love Microsoft’s approach to backwards compatibility, but the number one reason I turn on my Xbox One S is for Rock Band 4 and the hundreds of songs worth of DLC accumulated over the last 14 (!) years and six titles. Do you know how much it would cost me to download a digital version that works on Xbox Series S? $60. That’s 20% of the cost of the console itself, and that’s pretty annoying given I already own a perfectly good disk copy. There are other disk games I have, but most of those are on Game Pass or finished with. I’m in the tiny demographic for which plastic guitars and drums are a deciding factor in my next-gen gaming upgrade path.

Microsoft could win me over by releasing a version of the Xbox Series S with a disk drive — or even producing an optional add-on like the ill-fated Xbox 360 HD-DVD drive. I’d buy into that ecosystem, even if it ultimately cost me more than downloading Rock Band 4 from the Xbox Store (which seems silly now I write it down, but I’m nothing if not stubborn.)   

But the company clearly won’t be doing that. There’s a reason the Xbox Series S comes without a disk drive, and it’s to lock customers into Game Pass subscriptions, and purchasing all their games through a store that Microsoft owns. It neatly blocks off the pre-owned market and lets the company recoup costs lost through players not paying big bucks for a Series X. If Microsoft were to release a Series S with a disk drive, the company would likely up the price significantly to justify losing its exclusive ability to sell me Xbox software.

So, for now, me and Microsoft are at an impasse, and for as long as this stalemate continues, the Xbox One S gets to extend its streak as the oldest bit of tech in my living room. Things will come to a head when that Bethesda exclusivity kicks in, and I’ll have to decide whether my love of elaborate guitar solos trumps my love of the Fallout series. But for now, there’s life in the old Xbox yet.

Alan Martin

Freelance contributor Alan has been writing about tech for over a decade, covering phones, drones and everything in between. Previously Deputy Editor of tech site Alphr, his words are found all over the web and in the occasional magazine too. When not weighing up the pros and cons of the latest smartwatch, you'll probably find him tackling his ever-growing games backlog. Or, more likely, playing Spelunky for the millionth time.

Read more
PS5 vs Xbox Series X: Which console wins?
The era of console exclusives is slowly coming to an end — and I’m fine with that
Playing Metaphor ReFantazio on the Xbox Series X Digital Edition
Got a new Xbox Series X? Here are 5 games you need to play first
a photo representing the PS5 vs. Xbox Series X
PS5 vs. Xbox Series X: Which console wins?
Indiana Jones and the Great Circle screenshot
The best Xbox Series X games in 2025 — our top picks
The PlayStation logo on a PS5 Pro
PS6 won't completely abandon discs, says former PlayStation boss
Nintendo Switch 2 first look and detached Joy-Cons
The Nintendo Switch 2 just offered the best gaming feature — here's why I'm getting one
Latest in Xbox
Evil Shift Controller Xbox One
Microsoft may be designing a new Xbox controller with DualSense-like features — here's what we know
Playing Metaphor ReFantazio on the Xbox Series X Digital Edition
Got a new Xbox Series X? Here are 5 games you need to play first
Xbox Series X console with a Tom's Guide Black Friday deals tag
Xbox Black Friday deals — biggest savings on Series X, Series S and more
Xbox Game Pass logo above an Xbox controller
Microsoft will finally let you stream Xbox games you already own via Game Pass — here's what you can play right now
wd_black xbox expansion card deals
WD_Black’s 1TB Xbox Expansion Card just hit its lowest ever price — this is a killer Black Friday Xbox deal
seagate 2TB expansion card for xbox series x with a lowest price deal tag
Grab this 2TB Expansion Card for Xbox Series X — back at its lowest ever price
Latest in Opinion
Adam Scott as Mark S and Britt Lower as Helly R in Severance, standing by an elevator
My 5 biggest 'Severance' questions heading into season 2 episode 9
Google Pixel 9a render
Google Pixel 9a will have to fix one crucial thing to hold off its low-cost rivals
Brian Cox as Tommy Tilden in "The Autopsy of Jane Doe"
Netflix is about to lose one of the most unpredictable dark thrillers I’ve ever watched — stream it while you still can
Programmer sitting at a laptop and monitors
I write about AI for a living and 'vibe coding' is going to change everything — here's why
Josh Hartnett as Cooper in "Trap"
Netflix just got a twisting thriller movie that feels fresh — and there’s one thing about it that I love
Man performing push-ups in gym studio during workout
Doing exercise you dislike could have unexpected health benefits — here’s why