I own one of the most powerful gaming PCs money can buy — and I regret it

A photos of Dave Meikleham's gaming PC
(Image credit: Future)

Being a PC gamer has been tough of late. Thanks to the disastrous state of many recent PC ports, it’s increasingly hard to enjoy big-budget games, even if you own one of the best gaming PCs. It’s a situation that plainly sucks, and one that could stop many gamers from embracing PC hardware for years to come.

I’m currently writing this article while casting half a weary eye at the stupidly heavy rig sitting under my desk. It’s a colossus that would snap my shins if I ever tried to pick it up. Housing an Nvidia GeForce RTX 4090 GPU, 12th Gen Intel Core i5-12600K CPU, 32GB of DDR4 RAM and a couple of ultra-speedy NVMe SSDs, it’s a beast of a system. It’s also one that I kinda regret putting together. 

The sheer expense of assembling such a PC has been ruinous. Throw in a beefy PSU, two of the best gaming monitors, various liquid coolers and an ostentatious case crammed full of garish RGB, and I’m looking at an outlay well north of $7,000. That’s clearly ludicrous… and also shows why I should never be trusted with anything more than lunch money. 

The rig is up

The Last of Us Part 1 screenshot

(Image credit: Sony/Naughty Dog)

My tattered bank balance wouldn’t mind quite so much if I was regularly getting a demonstrably better gaming experience than is currently possible on PS5 or Xbox Series X

Sadly, that’s just not the case the majority of the time. With so many triple-A PC ports being released in such a depressing state, it’s becoming ever harder to justify owning a powerful gaming PC.

The Callisto Protocol, Elden Ring, Final Fantasy 7 Remake, Returnal, Forspoken, and more recently The Last of Us Part 1 have all been released with either game-breaking glitches or immersion-ruining stutter.

Over the last 12 months or so, there have been a host of PC ports that have launched in a completely unacceptable state. The bar has been set so low, a barebones PC version that runs without major issues is a cause for mild celebration in 2023. That’s just sad.

Regardless of the level of hardware, PC gamers have been served up an increasingly unpalatable buffet of underperforming ports. The Callisto Protocol, Elden Ring, Final Fantasy 7 Remake, Returnal, Forspoken, and more recently The Last of Us Part 1 have all been released with either game-breaking glitches or immersion-ruining stutter.

Stutter wouldn't melt

The Callisto Protocol

The Callisto Protocol's launch day stutter was uglier than its undead monsters.  (Image credit: Krafton)

Ah yes, stutter. The rise of PC games launching with horrible shader compilation stutter is seemingly becoming a bigger problem with every passing month. For its first few days on sale, ultra-gory survival horror The Callisto Protocol was all but unplayable because there was no way to pre-compile texture shaders before you played the game.

To bypass some of the technicalities, this basically, this basically resulted in extremely noticeable on-screen judders that even the highest-end PC owners couldn’t brute force their way through. 

A patch soon fixed the problem for many players. But months on, the grizzly sci-fi horror still stutters on my $2,000 GPU far more than it does on a $500 PS5.

And lessons clearly aren’t being learned. Within the last few weeks the PC port of The Last of Us Part I hit digital storefronts in a truly broken state. The constant stutter, array of bugs and unreasonably high VRAM requirements mean Naughty Dog’s apocalyptic adventure runs terribly on all but the very best PCs.

Even then, there’s no guarantee of a smooth, console-beating experience. Spoiler: The Last of Us is currently a stuttery mess on my GeForce RTX 4090, and that’s after the game took close to an hour to pre-compile its shaders from the main menu.

The Last of Us Part 1 Prologue

The Last of Us Part 1 is currently a hot mess on PC.  (Image credit: Future)

As more half-baked ports hit the market, it’s hard to shake the notion that PC games simply aren’t a priority for many major developers. It’s one of the reasons I’m starting to regret building such an expensive machine. 

The cost of PC gaming at the absolute highest level has always been prohibitively expensive, yet I can’t think of a time when owning so much high-end tech produced subpar results on such an alarming basis.

PS5 and Xbox Series X: Sofa so good

PS5 DualSense controller with Horizon Forbidden West game

(Image credit: Future)

With so many PS5 and Xbox Series X games shipping in a better state than their PC counterparts, I’m increasingly being lured to the couch when I want to play the latest big titles. More and more, playing games in a hassle-free environment is becoming my number one priority.

As much as I love playing games at 120 fps in 4K on PC, there aren’t enough modern titles taking advantage of my GPU’s power. It’s why I find myself regularly opting for the less technically advanced but ultimately smoother and more stable console experience.

Until the majority of PC ports are treated with more care, the justification for owning super powerful GPUs like the RTX 4090 or AMD RX 7900 continues to diminish. 

When you can buy one of the best OLED TVs and pair it with either a PS5 or Xbox Series X for a fraction of the price you’d spend on a 4K-capable PC, it’s not hard to see why the new consoles are selling in record-breaking numbers.

As a regretful RTX 4090 owner, I can only hope the state of PC ports gets a heck of a lot better in the near future.

More from Tom's Guide

Dave Meikleham
UK Computing Editor

Dave is a computing editor at Tom’s Guide and covers everything from cutting edge laptops to ultrawide monitors. When he’s not worrying about dead pixels, Dave enjoys regularly rebuilding his PC for absolutely no reason at all. In a previous life, he worked as a video game journalist for 15 years, with bylines across GamesRadar+, PC Gamer and TechRadar. Despite owning a graphics card that costs roughly the same as your average used car, he still enjoys gaming on the go and is regularly glued to his Switch. Away from tech, most of Dave’s time is taken up by walking his husky, buying new TVs at an embarrassing rate and obsessing over his beloved Arsenal. 

  • DasLooney
    How the hello-kitty did you wind up spending $7,000 on that? Only if you were a complete n00b that got parts from a 100% total ripoff scammer could this happen. And wind up with only an i5?! Makes no sense.
    Reply
  • COLGeek
    You spent way too much on an unbalanced system to make a poorly associated point regarding game ports.

    Maybe you should have consulted with members at Tom's Hardware to build a more appropriate system to improve your gaming experience.

    Bad game ports really can't be improved by more computing horsepower.
    Reply
  • USAFRet
    Bad software can't be fixed by throwing more hardware money at it.
    Reply
  • Technigeneric
    Lol, Tom's Hardware writer pairs i5 12600k w a 4090 to complain about pc gaming ... where do you find these fools?
    Reply
  • Technigeneric
    COLGeek said:
    You spent way too much on an unbalanced system to make a poorly associated point regarding game ports.

    Maybe you should have consulted with members at Tom's Hardware to build a more appropriate system to improve your gaming experience.

    Bad game ports really can't be improved by more computing horsepower.
    But if he had just went w an i3 and SLI another 4090, all of his problems would have been solved.
    Reply
  • rgd1101
    Technigeneric said:
    Lol, Tom's Hardware writer pairs i5 12600k w a 4090 to complain about pc gaming ... where do you find these fools?
    this is toms guide. could be a upgrade. some people just negative
    Reply
  • Technigeneric
    rgd1101 said:
    this is toms guide. could be a upgrade. some people just negative
    Some people get paid to write for pc hardware outlets and use that forum to complain about an entire ecosystem when they have an obvious cpu bottleneck which leads to ... guess what? ...STUTTERING. Bad takes deserve negativity, not your excuses that do not absolve the writer from needing to have a clue about what he's writing about.
    Reply
  • tcg101
    Lol. Not even close to the most powerful. And you spent way too much.
    Reply
  • Tactical Grace
    rgd1101 said:
    this is toms guide. could be a upgrade. some people just negative

    Whether it's an upgrade or not is irrelevant. The system is absurdly unbalanced, and in such a way that would absolutely cause stuttering and performance issues in almost all games, especially at higher framerates, and resolutions above 1080p. Making the claim that PC gaming is a waste of time or money, because you choose to own a PC that is poorly built, and then attempting to lay that blame on literally anything but your own incompetence, is absurd. That it appears on THIS website is just even more absurd.
    Reply
  • pereg
    Calling a game a pc port rather than call a game a console port I guess is the sign of the times. Even D4 is prioritizing the UI for console.
    Reply