I ditched my Apple Watch for the Pixel Watch and no, I’m not crazy

Google Pixel Watch
(Image credit: Future)

The news that Google’s Pixel Watch is selling more than Samsung smartwatches, according to data from industry analysts Canalys, surprised me a little. It’s a very first-generation smartwatch, in that it has a lovely design and a lot of promise but isn't quite there yet to really chase down the Apple Watch Series 8

Having claimed 8% of the smartwatch market share compared to Samsung’s 5.9%, the Pixel Watch is doing rather well. I’d hazard a guess that various Pixel Watch deals and a competitive price compared to the likes of the Galaxy Watch 5 broaden its appeal. But as I saw this news, I realized that I’m part of this Pixel Watch love-in.

Despite being a tech journalist for nearly a decade, I only really got into smartwatches in late 2020, when I snagged a Fossil Carlyle HR in a sale (I also had a gift card that dictated my choice of watch). Then around a year ago, I took possession of an Apple Watch SE that was hanging around in a Tom’s Guide locker.  

Wear OS to watchOS and back again

Google Pixel Watch

(Image credit: Future)

Moving from a dated Google Watch OS wearable to Apple’s watchOS experience was like stepping out of a dark cave into beaming sunlight. While far from the best Apple Watch, the SE was nicer to use, had a better display, and offered far more functionality than the Fossil smartwatch, which could be remarkably glitchy.

As a result, the Apple Watch SE became a regular fixture for my wrist. 

Even when the Pixel Watch arrived, I remained skeptical of it in the face of the superior Apple Watch; it didn't seem to have any outstanding features and looked to be more of a Fitbit-centric device than a perfect partner for a Pixel phone.

So why have I ditched Cupertino’s wearable for the Pixel Watch? Fashion darling, fashion.

Rah rah fashion baby

an image of the Google Pixel Watch on a wrist

(Image credit: Future)

Unlike a lot of U.K. tech journalists, I eschew the standard check (I think that’s plaid in American) shirt and hooded top combo for neater polo tops, some form of blazer for the likes of Reiss or Paul Smith and tailored jeans from Ted Baker (I’m really good at finding costly brands on sale). While I may physically be an overweight unshaven mess, my sartorial choices are pretty solid. But the Apple Watch SE never really fit my fit.

Granted, tech YouTuber extraordinaire MKBHD may have worn an Apple Watch to last year’s Met Gala. But he rocked a matte black model — and is undoubtedly cooler than this bumbling Brit— whereas my SE has a clunky blue rubber strap and a silver body. And I found it felt more like I was wearing a mini computer on my wrist than a watch with some extra brains.

Sure, the functionality of watchOS and the Apple Watches remain unbeatable and still feel futuristic. But I’m not on The Expanse’s Rocinante, I’m in London, one of the world’s fashion capitals.

Equally, I’m still a tech journalist and I need a device to ping me notifications for various meetings or Slack alerts. Enter the Pixel Watch.

I think it looks great. The dark rounded face may hide big bezels, but on the wrist, you won’t notice them. The dark face contrasts nicely against the gold-ish colored crown and body, while the light gray rubber strap is clean and neat, giving off a minimalist Scandinavian design vibe.

As such, the Pixel Watch simply works neatly riding under the sleeve of a blazer, as much as it does on a rugged denim shirt or mac coat. And with one watch face that looks a bit like that of a traditional watch from a modernist independent brand, it scratches that itch I think people in their 30s get towards wanting a nice watch... or several.

an image of the Google Pixel Watch on a wrist

(Image credit: Future)

Of course, I fully accept that I’m getting an inferior smartwatch experience when compared to an Apple Watch. But I don’t really care. 

Unlike my more active colleagues, I’m ambivalent about all the health-centric features of watchOS. All I really need is notifications, calendar access, a reliable step counter and control over Spotify. The Pixel Watch ticks these boxes and does so in style.

There are caveats. As an iPhone 13 Pro user, which the Pixel Watch doesn't work with, I do need to carry around my Pixel 7 Pro or do without many of the smart features. This isn’t ideal and I wish Google would open the Pixel Watch app to iOS. And battery life for the Pixel Watch isn't exactly impressive.

But for what I need from a smartwatch, the Pixel Watch has grown on me a lot and now finds its place on my wrist almost every day; didn't think I’d be saying that. Hopefully, 2023 will have more tech surprises... looking at you iPhone 15 Pro Max

More from Tom's Guide

Roland Moore-Colyer

Roland Moore-Colyer a Managing Editor at Tom’s Guide with a focus on news, features and opinion articles. He often writes about gaming, phones, laptops and other bits of hardware; he’s also got an interest in cars. When not at his desk Roland can be found wandering around London, often with a look of curiosity on his face. 

Read more
The 41mm and 45mm Pixel Watch on a red table with accessories
Google Pixel Watch 3 review: Third time’s the charm
A close-up of five smartwatch on a wooded surface including the Apple Watch SE, Samsung Galaxy Watch Ultra, Google Pixel Watch 3 XL, Apple Watch 10 and Samsung Galaxy Watch 7
Best smartwatch tested and rated: 2025 top picks
OnePlus Watch 3 watch face
OnePlus Watch 3 review: Good becomes great
Close-up of the Amazfit Active 2 and Apple Watch SE next to each other on a user's wrist
I put the Apple Watch SE vs Amazfit Active 2 through a 7-round face-off — here's the winner
Google Pixel Watch 3 on a desk next to a Pixel 9 smartphone showing the pairing process
How to set up your new Google Pixel Watch 3
A close up of the Samsung Galaxy Watch 7 and Google Pixel Watch 3 next to on another with an out of focus background
Best smartwatches for Android in 2025: Tested and rated
Latest in Smartwatches
Apple Watch Series 10
Future Apple Watch models could get a surprising new feature — what we know
The coolest things the Apple Watch can do
A folding Apple Watch could follow the iPhone Flip — here’s what we know
Atari 2600 My Play Watch
It's not just Pebble — Atari is back with a watch that lets you play retro games on your wrist
Pebble Core 2 Duo and Core Time 2 smartwatches
Pebble is back with two new smartwatches starting at $149 — how to preorder
Garmin Fenix 8 Sleep
New data reveals the average Garmin sleep score — do you sleep better or worse than most people?
Garmin Fenix 8 deal
Act fast! Unexpected discount sees Garmin Fenix 8 drop to its lowest price on Amazon
Latest in Opinion
A Samsung DU7200 LED TV on a side table
I'm a TV reviewer — here's the one type of TV I wouldn't buy
A distraction-free desk setup built around the Oakywood Standing Desk Pro
I built the ultimate work-from-home setup with this vertical monitor — and it’s a game changer for my productivity
iPhone Flip Concept
iPhone Flip should have been released years ago — it's time Apple started taking risks again
Nintendo Switch 2
Nintendo Switch 2 — these are the 5 launch games that would make me buy on day one
the dyson airwrap ID in teal and terracotta colorway (patina and orange) with a lapis case, with a brush, hairfryer, curling wand attachments
I'm so sick of everything being 'smart' — and the Dyson Airwrap i.d. I've been testing is the last straw
a photo of a woman doing a plank outside
I did 70 walking plank push-ups every day for one week — here’s what happened to my upper body