This new show just beat The Boys on Prime Video

Antony Starr as Homelander in The Boys
(Image credit: Prime Video)

The Boys is one of the best Prime Video shows, but it’s no longer the number 1 TV series on the service. That’s because it just got dethroned by a new show, The Summer I Turned Pretty.

The third season of Amazon's comic book-adaptation just released its fifth episode. this past Friday. The adaptation of Garth Ennis’ and Darick Robertson’s comic series has always been good, but season 3 has pushed that to new highs. Unfortunately, good doesn’t always beat new, and The Summer I Turned Pretty has stolen the top spot for itself (as seen on Prime Video's own top 10 rankings on its homepage). And The Summer I Turned Pretty season 2 is in the works!

What is The Summer I Turned Pretty about? 

The Summer I Turned Pretty is based on Jenny Han’s young adult romance novel of the same name. It follows Isabel “Belly” Conklin (Lola Tung) on her annual summer vacation to a family friends’ beach house.

Belly is reunited with her friends, brothers Jeremiah (Gavin Casalegno) and Conrad (Christopher Briney), the latter of whom she’s had a crush on for years. However, as Conrad begins to return Belly’s affections, it seems as though Jeremiah is vying for her attention putting Belly in the middle of a love triangle.

In other words, it’s different from The Boys in almost every respect. Even if the show does have its own fake love triangle between Homelander, Starlight and Hughie.

What do critics think of The Summer I Turned Pretty? 

The Summer I Turned Pretty seems to be a hit with critics and audiences alike, with Rotten Tomatoes reporting an 82% score from critic reviews and 90% from audiences. The show also has a 7.8/10 score on IMDB.

Abby Cavenaugh of Collider noted that while the show isn’t a word-for-word adaptation of the book, the seven-part series is likely to delight fans of Han’s trilogy of novels. AV Club's Lauren Chval found that “the characters feel lived in, with warm chemistries and rich histories that suggest they are well known by their creator” with a B+ score.

That’s not to say critics don’t have their issues with it. Angie Han, of The Hollywood Reporter, said that the show is a “solid coming-of-ager wrapped in a not-so-good romance”. Amy Amatangelo of Paste Magazine was less kind, noting that while the show tried to capture the idea of first love, growing up and finding your own way, none of it quite works — giving the show a 5.8/10.

Christopher Briney as Conrad, Lola Tung as Isabel "Belly" Conklin and Gavin Casalegno as Jeremiah in The Summer I Turned Pretty poster art

(Image credit: Amazon Studios)

Should you watch The Summer I Turned Pretty? 

Yes, but also no. It all depends on where your tastes lie. If you’re a fan of The Boys, then you’ll know that the show is a scathing indictment of multiple aspects of the modern world. Whether that’s superheroes obsessions, corporate power and greed, police brutality, or extremist politics. All with a liberal helping of sex, violence, swearing and gross, irreverent humor.

The Summer I Turned Pretty is a serious teenage coming of age drama, with, well, none of that. It all depends on how varied your tastes are, and whether you enjoy this kind of content. We suspect that there are plenty of people out there with room to enjoy both, so don’t let any of that deter you. Just know what you’re getting yourself in for.

The good news is Amazon released all seven The Summer I Turned Pretty episodes at the same time. That means you can watch through the entire first season should it take your fancy. The show has also been renewed for a second season, which will presumably continue to adapt the story from Han’s trilogy. Though how much will come from the second book, It’s Not Summer Without You, is unclear.

Can The Boys reclaim the top spot? 

Possibly. The thing to remember here is that The Boys and The Summer I Turned Pretty couldn’t be more different. If you watched the first 15 minutes of The Boys’ third season premiere, you’ll know exactly why. It’s not the kind of subject matter you have in most adult-oriented shows, let alone a young adult romance.

The Summer I Turned Pretty’s first season was released in one go, which may cause its ongoing popularity to decline. Similarly, The Boys' upcoming sixth episode, titled Herogasm, is going to adapt one of the more infamous storylines from the comics. 

I won’t spoil any potential plots, but the scale of sex and violence in the show is nothing compared to what Herogasm could have on show.

Plus: We've got the 7 best new movies to stream this week on Netflix, HBO Max, Disney Plus and more. Don't forget to check out some of the best new shows and movies to stream, alongside a classic competitive cooking show that just got a Netflix reboot.

Tom Pritchard
UK Phones Editor

Tom is the Tom's Guide's UK Phones Editor, tackling the latest smartphone news and vocally expressing his opinions about upcoming features or changes. It's long way from his days as editor of Gizmodo UK, when pretty much everything was on the table. He’s usually found trying to squeeze another giant Lego set onto the shelf, draining very large cups of coffee, or complaining about how terrible his Smart TV is.

Read more
Lala (Taryn Delanie Smith) and Quinn (Grace Byers) in "Harlem" season 3
Prime Video top 10 shows — here’s the 3 worth watching right now
American Primeval
Netflix top 10 shows — here's the 3 worth watching right now
The Boys season 4 poster featuring Antony Starr as Homelander
'The Boys' season 5: Everything we know so far
Christopher Briney as Conrad and Lola Tung as Belly in The Summer I Turned Pretty
Prime Video top 10 shows — here’s the 3 worth watching right now
Taylor Kitsch and Betty Gilpin in "American Primeval" coming soon to Netflix
Netflix's top 10 has 3 great shows to stream right now — and one's a brutal Western thriller
(l to r) Máiréad Tyers as Jen and Sofia Oxenham as Carrie salute on Extraordinary
Hulu's 'Extraordinary' was one of my favorite shows of the last 5 years — and it just got canceled
Latest in Prime Video
Cruel Intentions on Prime Video
Amazon cancels 'Cruel Intentions' after one season on Prime Video
Will Smith as Robert Clayton Dean in "Enemy of the State"
This action-thriller with Will Smith and Gene Hackman just crashed Prime Video’s top 10 — now's the perfect time to stream it
Nina Oyama and Kate Box in Deadloch
One of my favorite shows on Prime Video has been totally overlooked — and it's got 100% on Rotten Tomatoes
Prime Video logo appears on a tablet surrounded by a can of soda, spilled popcorn, headphones and a cactus
7 new to Prime Video movies with 90% or higher on Rotten Tomatoes
Christopher Briney as Conrad and Lola Tung as Belly in The Summer I Turned Pretty
Prime Video top 10 shows — here’s the 3 worth watching right now
Betty Gilpin as Crystal May Creasey in "The Hunt"
5 must-watch thriller movies you can stream for free on Prime Video
Latest in News
Try Galaxy home screen on iPhone 16 Pro Max
You can now try Samsung's latest One UI 7 software on your iPhone — here's how
Asus ROG Ally X
Xbox handheld reportedly being made with Asus — all to take on Steam Deck
A person typing on a laptop with warning messages displayed on screen
240 million Windows users under attack — update your PC now before hackers strike
Genshin Impact on a OnePlus Nord 4
Genshin Impact on Android finally adds controller support — 4 years after iOS
A render of the iPhone 17 Pro Max
iPhone 17 Pro and Pro Max just tipped for this performance secret weapon
Google Play logo on an android smartphone with corner hole punch camera
At least 5 North Korean spy apps have been found on Google Play — what you need to know