PS5 cross-gen saves are a mess — here's why

Dirt 5
(Image credit: Codemasters)

The PS5 has suffered another blow after the upcoming rally racing game Dirt 5 has announced that it too is unable to transfer PS4 saves to the next-gen PlayStation. 

This has come directly from game developer Codemasters, in a reply to a user from the official Dirt Twitter account. Dirt 5 is letting PlayStation and Xbox users upgrade their game to the new generation for free. However exactly what can be transferred over differs between the two. 

Moving a PS4 save to the PS5 will keep users' Playgrounds, their custom-made racing and stunt arenas. But progression data from the career mode, and the user's currency and liveries will not. Meanwhile the Xbox, all progress can be transferred between the Xbox One and Xbox Series X.

This follows similar irritating news from Sega that Yakuza: Like A Dragon will also be unable to transfer PS4 saves to the PS5, despite offering a free upgrade to a next-gen version of the game. Yet it's not that it's impossible for Sony to offer cross-generation saves - that's exactly what it's offering with the Spider-Man remaster.

This isn't a problem you'll face on the Xbox Series X. Microsoft's Smart Delivery feature promising that you will be able to own a single copy of a game that works on Xbox One, Xbox Series X and PC, with the ability to transfer saves between them.

As Eurogamer noted, Xbox Live director of programming Larry Hryb and Xbox Games marketing general manager Aaron Greenberg made tweets hinting at how these issues aren't a problem on the Xbox ecosystem. Even if you're a PlayStation owner, the ability to move games between your gaming PC and consoles without a hindrance is a compelling reason to pick up a Series X over a PS5, even if you lose out on cross-generation benefits.

The PS5, the Xbox Series X and the Xbox Series S are on pre-order sale now, with both Sony and Microsoft releasing their new consoles properly in November. Although the PS5 lacks the Series X's Smart Delivery ability and has a slightly less powerful GPU, it does offer additional features for game immersion, like the new DualSense controller and 3D audio capabilities.

Richard Priday
Assistant Phones Editor

Richard is based in London, covering news, reviews and how-tos for phones, tablets, gaming, and whatever else people need advice on. Following on from his MA in Magazine Journalism at the University of Sheffield, he's also written for WIRED U.K., The Register and Creative Bloq. When not at work, he's likely thinking about how to brew the perfect cup of specialty coffee.

Latest in Playstation
The PlayStation Portal on a counter with the start screen for Horizon Forbidden West
PlayStation Portal just got upgraded cloud streaming features — here’s what’s new
God of War Ragnarok
PlayStation’s epic March sale is live with PS5 games from $3 — here’s 17 deals I’d buy
Horizon Forbidden West on PC
AI-powered PlayStation characters are being tested at Sony — what we know
The Last of Us Part I screenshot with a Tom's Guide deal tag
PlayStation launches new sale with big discounts on essential PS5 games — here’s my 17 favorite deals from $2
PS VR2 headset with PS VR2 Sense controllers
PlayStation VR2 getting a $200 price drop in March — is it worth buying now?
The PlayStation logo on a PS5 Pro
Ex-Sony executive predicts the PS6 will arrive in 2028 — what you need to know
Latest in News
Apple Watch Ultra 2
Apple Watch Ultra 3 just tipped for two major upgrades
NYTimes Connections
NYT Connections today hints and answers — Tuesday, March 25 (#653)
A first look at Amazon's Fallout TV series coming to Prime Video
‘Fallout’ season 3 plans are reportedly being made — while season 2 is still filming
Surface Laptop 7 from the front
Amazon just gave Surface Laptop 7 a 'frequently returned' label — here's what's going on
New emojis with iOS 18.4 beta release.
iOS 18.4 beta brings 8 new emoji to your iPhone — here's all the new options
23andME box
23andMe has declared bankruptcy — here's how to delete your data now