New study reveals huge reason to buy iPhones over Samsung Galaxy

galaxy s21 plus vs iphone 12 pro
(Image credit: Tom's Guide)

If you're struggling to pick between the latest iPhone 12 and Samsung Galaxy S21, a new study confirms one of Apple's chief advantages over its rival.

All phones lose value over time. However, there's an enormous difference between the value lost from the iPhone 12 and Galaxy S21. And the iPhone 12 has been on the market longer.

Research by second-hand phone site SellCell has found that despite launching just three months ago, Samsung Galaxy S21 handsets are already worth as little as 43% of their original value, in the case of the 256GB model of the Galaxy S21. On the other hand, the worst depreciating model from Apple, the basic 64GB iPhone 12, sells for about 67.3% of its original price.

The base iPhone 12 Pro Max, with 128GB of storage, has held its value the best out of all the phones examined in this report. It's only lost 18.1% of its value since it launched in October 2020. Samsung's best performer was the Galaxy S21 Plus with 128GB of storage, but it has still lost 44.8% of its value.

It makes sense that iPhones retain value better, according to the later part of SellCell's report. It notes that iPhone users are much more likely to remain loyal to Apple than Samsung users are to Samsung. With fewer iPhones being sold off as people swap to new devices, it follows that they keep a higher price.

Why exactly that is will vary between customers. iPhones are consistently some of the best phones you can buy, but Apple is also very skilled at maintaining its walled garden ecosystem. Android users can swap brands and still get a roughly equivalent experience, whereas iPhone users get a unique experience that works very differently, and perhaps makes them unwilling to swap sides.

What these numbers show is that iPhone 12 users are in a better spot to get the majority of their money back should they sell them or get a good deal when trading them in. However, if you're trying to get a fairly new phone on the cheap, it seems like you can get a great deal by looking around for a cheap pre-owned Galaxy S21.

TOPICS
Richard Priday
Assistant Phones Editor

Richard is based in London, covering news, reviews and how-tos for phones, tablets, gaming, and whatever else people need advice on. Following on from his MA in Magazine Journalism at the University of Sheffield, he's also written for WIRED U.K., The Register and Creative Bloq. When not at work, he's likely thinking about how to brew the perfect cup of specialty coffee.

Read more
Samsung Galaxy A56 (left) and iPhone 16e (right) laying next to each other on a woodgrain table.
4 reasons why Samsung's Galaxy A56 is a better buy than the iPhone 16e
Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra vs iPhone 16 Pro Max.
Galaxy S25 Ultra vs iPhone 16 Pro Max — 7 ways Samsung beats Apple
Samsung Galaxy s25 next to iPhone 16
Samsung Galaxy S25 vs. iPhone 16: Which phone could win?
Samsung Galaxy S25 vs the Galaxy S24
Samsung Galaxy S25 vs Galaxy S24: Biggest upgrades
Galaxy Unpacked 2025 event
I covered Samsung's Galaxy S25 launch and I saw 5 things Apple should learn for its iPhone releases
iPhone 14 vs iPhone 13
iPhone 14 vs. iPhone 13: Which iPhone should you buy?
Latest in Phones
The four Pixel 9a colors stacked on top of each other with a focus on the camera of the Iris model
Google Pixel 9a vs Pixel 10 — buy now or wait?
iPhone 16 Pro vs iPhone 16 Pro Max in hand showing displays
Forget iPhone 17 — iPhone 18 could get this huge upgrade
Rendered images of rumored foldable iPhone.
Foldable iPhone report just revealed key details — here's what we know
iPhone 17 Pro render
iPhone 17 Pro — 7 biggest rumored upgrades
CAD renderings of the Google Pixel 10 Pro XL
Pixel 10 leak could be good news for all Android phones
An image of an iPhone screen showing the Safari app icon in the center
I got tired of Safari revealing my web searches in iOS 18.4 — this setting fixes that
Latest in News
iPhone 16 Pro vs iPhone 16 Pro Max in hand showing displays
Forget iPhone 17 — iPhone 18 could get this huge upgrade
The new Husqvarna iQ series robot lawn mower.
Husqvarna’s new robot mowers offer GPS for less
Rendered images of rumored foldable iPhone.
Foldable iPhone report just revealed key details — here's what we know
NYTimes Connections
NYT Connections today hints and answers — Sunday, March 23 (#651)
NYT Strands on a cellphone
NYT Strands today — hints, spangram and answers for game #385 (Sunday, March 23 2025)
Nintendo Switch 2
Nintendo Switch 2 rumored specs — here’s what we know so far
  • rzimbauer
    In other words: "The Samsung S21 currently has more value for money than iPhone 12, even though it's a newer phone."
    Reply