Netflix just canceled The Midnight Club after one season — and its creator has the perfect response

The cast of The Midnight Club on Netflix
(Image credit: Netflix)

It’s been a few months since we saw a high-profile Netflix cancellation, and while that streak was refreshing it was always likely to end sooner rather than later. After all, the streamer has developed a reputation for swiftly canceling shows, often after just a single season, for good reason. 

Variety reports that The Midnight Club is the latest victim of Netflix’s cancelation axe, as the mystery-thriller series has been officially canned after just one season. Created by Mike Flanagan, the creative behind Netflix horror hits The Haunting of Hill House and Midnight Mass, the show spanned just 10 episodes in total but was intended to last much longer. 

Based on the beloved Christopher Pike novel of the same name, The Midnight Club debuted on Netflix in October. The show follows a group of terminally ill youngsters living in a hospice who meet at Midnight to tell spooky stories. When one of the group dies, bizarre events begin to happen, and the dark history of the hospice comes to light. 

The show earned a fairly strong critical reception with an 87% rating on Rotten Tomatoes. It also appeared to enjoy viewership success out of the gate peaking at No. 2 on the Netflix most-watched list in its first week. Although, this initially strong subscriber response may not have translated into long-term interest as the show quickly dropped out of the top 10. Plus, its 55% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes is less than impressive. 

While Flanagan’s previous Netflix projects were pitched as limited series, The Midnight Club was supposed to run for multiple seasons.“[The Midnight Club] is very much designed to continue. Pike has 80 books, so we have a lot of unused material to pull from. We also didn’t answer some of the bigger questions of the season. Those answers exist, but were meant to be for the next season,” said Flanagan at a press event in October. 

Variety also notes the show’s cancelation comes in the wake of Flanagan and collaborator Trevor Macy exiting their multi-year deal with Netflix in order to work with Amazon Studios and presumably make content for Prime Video — which could be a factor. 

Unfortunately, whether it’s the lack of long-term interest from subscribers or disappointment at losing a valued creative to a rival platformer, Netflix has decided that The Midnight Club season 2 won’t be happening. For now, The Midnight Club will be joining a new group: the list of Netflix canceled shows in 2022

There’s a silver lining for Midnight Club members

Often when a show is canceled by Netflix the creator will take a pot shot at the streamer on social media, or might request fans launch a campaign to get the show revived (an effort that is almost always fruitless). However, Mike Flanagan has instead responded to the news that The Midnight Club is canceled in the perfect way. 

The first season of the show ends with several unresolved mysteries, and there were also plenty of nods at events planned to occur in a second season. However, instead of leaving these plot threads hanging, Flanagan has put together a lengthy blog post detailing what would have happened in The Midnight Club season 2, and you can read it right here

For passionate fans of the show, this blog post likely won’t make up for the disappointment of its cancellation, but it’s an appreciated move from Flanagan nevertheless. Other Netflix shows canceled this year such as Messiah and Archive 81 ended on cliffhangers but viewers were given no resolution whatsoever. At least The Midnight Club fans have been given a little closure even if it’s not in the format that most would ideally want. 

Sadly, Flanagan’s opting to explain future plans for the show in this way definitely suggests The Midnight Club isn’t being shopped to other networks or streaming platforms. The club can now be considered disbanded. While it’s a bittersweet blog post overall, as Flanagan notes: “It's a shame we won't get to make [The Midnight Club season 2], but it would be a bigger shame if you guys simply had to live with the unanswered questions and the cliffhanger ending.”

Next: Bullet Train just soared to No. 1 on Netflix — stream it or skip it? We've also got the best new movies on HBO Max, Netflix and more this week, which finds George Clooney and Julia Roberts reunited.

Rory Mellon
Entertainment Editor (UK)

Rory is an Entertainment Editor at Tom’s Guide based in the UK. He covers a wide range of topics but with a particular focus on gaming and streaming. When he’s not reviewing the latest games, searching for hidden gems on Netflix, or writing hot takes on new gaming hardware, TV shows and movies, he can be found attending music festivals and getting far too emotionally invested in his favorite football team. 

Read more
(l to r) Máiréad Tyers as Jen and Sofia Oxenham as Carrie salute on Extraordinary
Hulu's 'Extraordinary' was one of my favorite shows of the last 5 years — and it just got canceled
Somebody Somewhere; Kaos; My Lady Jane
7 best canceled shows of 2024 that deserved another season
Emily Lawson (Anna Torv) and Susie Lawson (Philippa Northeast) (L-R) on horseback in Netflix's "Territory"
Netflix just canceled its ‘Yellowstone’-inspired drama after one season — and I’m not surprised anymore
"The Recruit" and "The Night Agent" in a composite image.
'The Night Agent' probably got 'The Recruit' canceled — here's why
Omar J. Dorsey (front), Sebastian Maniscalco in Max's "Bookie".
Max just canceled this comedy series with 90% on Rotten Tomatoes after just two seasons
Stella Maeve, Olivia Taylor Dudley, and Summer Bishil in The Magicians (2015)
My favorite fantasy drama is a dark, sexy, grown-up version of ‘Harry Potter’ — binge it before it leaves Netflix
Latest in Netflix
L-R: Claude (Marco Calvani), Danny (Colman Domingo), Kate (Tina Fey) and Jack (Will Forte) have their bags packed for Netflix's "The Four Seasons"
Netflix just teased a new comedy series starring Tina Fey, Steve Carrell and Colman Domingo — and we already have a release date
Ensemble cast members of Netflix's "The Residence" cast peak around a doorway
I just started streaming 'The Residence' — Netflix's new murder mystery show already has me hooked
Michelle (Millie Bobby Brown) , Keats (Chris Pratt) and Dr. Amherst (Ke Huy Quan) in "The Electric State" on Netflix
'The Electric State' is a total fail — and proof that Netflix has a blockbuster movie problem
Ryu Jun-yeol as Sung Min-chan and Shin Min-jae as Kwon Yang-rae in "Revelations" on Netflix
Netflix’s new psychological thriller is one of the best movies I’ve seen in 2025 so far — stream it now
Cristin Milioti in "Black Mirror" season 7 coming to Netflix
5 biggest Netflix movies and shows I can’t wait to watch in spring 2025
Netflix
3 Netflix movies I'm adding to my watchlist before they leave this month
Latest in News
Rendered images of rumored foldable iPhone.
Foldable iPhone report just revealed key details — here's what we know
NYTimes Connections
NYT Connections today hints and answers — Saturday, March 23 (#651)
NYT Strands on a cellphone
NYT Strands today — hints, spangram and answers for game #385 (Sunday, March 23 2025)
Nintendo Switch 2
Nintendo Switch 2 rumored specs — here’s what we know so far
iPhone 17 Pro render
iPhone 17 Pro — 7 biggest rumored upgrades
CAD renderings of the Google Pixel 10 Pro XL
Pixel 10 leak could be good news for all Android phones