Luckiest Girl Alive is new No. 1 Netflix movie — but critics and audiences are split

Mila Kunis as TifAni "Ani" Fanelli in Netflix's Luckiest Girl Alive
(Image credit: Netflix)

Luckiest Girl Alive may have only landed on Netflix a few days ago (Friday, October 7 to be specific) but the thriller has already climbed the streamer’s Top 10 most-watched list and currently sits in the No. 1 spot. 

The movie became Netflix’s latest chart-topper after displacing horror film Mr. Harrington’s Phone which previously held the top spot. However, while subscribers seem to be enjoying the twisty mystery flick that stars Mila Kunis, critics aren’t quite as convinced. 

What is Luckiest Girl Alive about?  

Luckiest Girl Alive sees Mila Kunis play TifAni “Ani” Fanelli, a sharp-tongued New Yorker with a highly sought-after position at a glossy magazine. Not only does she have her career fully figured out, but Ani also has a killer wardrobe and is currently planning her dream wedding with the perfect man. 

However, her meticulously crafted life threatens to unravel when the director of a true crime documentary reaches out and asks her to recount her side of a shocking incident that took place in her teenage years at the prestigious Brentley School. As hidden truths come to light, everything Ani has built could ruined. Maybe her luck has finally run out. 

Alongside Kunis, the movie also stars Connie Britton, Finn Wittrock, Scoot McNairy, Justine Lupe and Thomas Barbusca. It’s based on the 2015 novel of the same name by Jessica Knoll, which has drawn many comparisons to the global best-seller Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn. 

What do critics say about Luckiest Girl Alive? 

Netflix Original movies have a habit of being fairly divisive usually receiving a warmer reception from viewers than critics, and Luckiest Girl Alive is no exception. The thriller currently scores a fairly low 43% on Rotten Tomatoes from critics, but its audience score is a much more positive 77%.  

Noel Murray of the Los Angeles Times wasn’t particularly impressed claiming the movie “falls into the trap of trying too hard to capture not just the book’s flashback-heavy plot but also its distinctive voice." The Guardian’s Adrian Horton was similarly critical saying “the story [Luckiest Girl Alive] ultimately tells is an empty, self-serving fantasy.”

Amy Nicholson of the New York Times was a little more positive, writing “Kunis’s alpha female appears at once ferocious and like a conspicuous sham.” As was Deadline’s Todd McCarthy who labeled the film “formulaic” but also suggested that “the story nonetheless confronts the persistence of guilt over past questionable behavior and how people struggle to deal with it, even long after the fact." 

Should you stream Luckiest Girl Alive?  

Luckiest Girl Alive appears to be going down well with Netflix subscribers, and the film’s rapid ascension to the top of the streaming service’s most-watched list is a clear indication of a high level of interest. Critics aren’t particularly impressed, but that’s not necessarily a reason to instantly dismiss this one. 

If you like films in the vein of Gone Girl and The Girl on the Train, then Luckiest Girl Alive is definitely worth adding to your watchlist. Mila Kunis is a very capable lead and the plot has more than enough surprising twists to keep you hooked for the entire two-hour running time. As far as Netflix movies go, you could do a whole lot worse than Luckiest Girl Alive. 

Read next: The 7 best new movies to watch this week on Netflix, HBO Max and more. It's finale time with She-Hulk episode 9! Here's what the She-Hulk finale needs.

TOPICS
Rory Mellon
Entertainment Editor (UK)

Rory is an Entertainment Editor at Tom’s Guide based in the UK. He covers a wide range of topics but with a particular focus on gaming and streaming. When he’s not reviewing the latest games, searching for hidden gems on Netflix, or writing hot takes on new gaming hardware, TV shows and movies, he can be found attending music festivals and getting far too emotionally invested in his favorite football team. 

Read more
Megan Fox and Bruce Willis in "Midnight in the Switchgrass" (2021)
Netflix just got a crime thriller movie that’s already crashed the top 10 — but there’s a problem
David Oyelowo as Detective Jack Radcliff in "Don't Let Go"
This new to Netflix mystery thriller just crashed the top 10 — and viewers disagree with critics
Naomi Ackie and Channing Tatum in "Blink Twice" (2024)
Prime Video just got one of the best psychological thrillers of 2024 — and it’s a chilling watch
Shailene Woodley as Eleanor Falco in "To Catch a Killer"
Netflix just added a crime thriller you (probably) haven’t seen — and it’s packed with mystery
Maria Debska in "Just One Look" now streaming on Netflix
Netflix’s new mystery thriller show is now streaming — and it should be your next binge watch
Anya Taylor-Joy as Margot in the film THE MENU
One of the best dark thriller movies ever just crashed Netflix’s top 10 — ‘The Menu’ is a full-course psychological feast
Latest in Netflix
Michelle Buteau in Survival of the Thickest season 2
Netflix’s most underrated comedy ‘Survival of the Thickest’ is back — and I couldn’t be happier
Ensemble cast members of Netflix's "The Residence" cast peak around a doorway
Netflix top 10 shows — here's the 3 worth watching right now
(L-R) Ambika Mod as Emma Morley and Leo Woodall as Dexter Mayhew in One Day on Netflix
5 Netflix shows I wish I could erase from my memory just to relive them again
Tom Hiddleston as Robert Laing in "High Rise" now streaming on Netflix
5 best Netflix movies in March you haven't watched yet
Jason Schwartzman and Carol Kane in Between the Temples
My favorite rom-com from the last year is one you probably haven't heard of — and it's now streaming on Netflix
Maria Debska in "Just One Look" now streaming on Netflix
3 best Netflix shows in March you haven't watched yet
Latest in News
NYTimes Connections
NYT Connections today hints and answers — Thursday, March 27 (#655)
iOS 18.4 logo on an iPhone
iOS 18.4 brings a bunch of helpful upgrades to your iPhone — and this is my favorite
The Signal app logo displayed on an iPhone, with a screenshot of the Signal app in use displayed on a monitor in the background.
Signal — everything you need to know about the app at the center of the group chat scandal
Robert Downey Jr. revealed as Doctor Doom for "Avengers: Doomsday"
Marvel reveals 'Avengers: Doomsday' casting — the latest updates and every actor
Wyze Cam v3
Wyze adds AI-powered filter to its security cameras to cut down on notifications that are “no big deal”
Mark Grayson (Steven Yeun) as Invincible in his blue suit during a scene from "Invincible" season 3 on Prime Video.
'Invincible' season 4 release window just announced — here's when it's coming