Apple Watch ban could potentially move forward as Biden upholds ITC ruling

Google Maps app for Apple Watch
(Image credit: Future)

It could become difficult to get an Apple Watch with high-end health tracking features as President Joe Biden has upheld a U.S. International Trade Commission ruling that could potentially ban the import of Apple’s smartwatches. 

This all stems from a medical device brand AliveCor claiming Apple had infringed its patent relating to electrocardiogram (EKG) tech. Late last year, a final determination by the ITC found that Apple has indeed violated AliveCor’s patent and that there should be “a limited exclusion order and a cease and desist order” for Apple Watches sporting EKG. 

And now a Presidential review has seen this ruling get upheld. If enforced, it could mean Apple will be limited in importing Apple Watch models with EKG features to sell in the U.S. 

Now before you rush out and panic buy the likes of the Apple Watch Series 8 or Apple Watch Ultra, this ruling isn’t likely to have an immediate impact. Apple spokesperson Hannah Smith told The Verge that the Patent Trial and Appeal Board ruled that AliveCor’s EKG tech might not actually be patent-worthy and thus AliveCor would need to appeal that decision before the ITC’s ruling could come into effect. 

Patent disputes are all rather complex, but the crux of this issue is AliveCor isn't the only one seeking an import ban on Apple Watches. Med-tech company Masimo also accused Apple of infringing five of its patents based on pulse oximetry; a decision on whether this warrants an import ban will be made in May by the ITC. 

If your head is spinning from all this, then in simple terms if Apple fails to appeal these decisions and an import ban comes into effect, it could make getting an Apple Watch 6 or newer models difficult in the U.S. That’s unless Apple were to agree to pay licensing fees, something that could be rather costly for the company. 

Overall, such patent battles are both a blessing and a curse. Companies that sit on patents can limit innovation, effectively claiming technology concepts but not bringing them to market. Equally, keeping some tech limited to patent holders can encourage competition and innovation, forcing brands that don’t want to pay licensing fees to come up with their own new technology. 

Nevertheless, if you want one of Cupertino’s best smartwatches, we suggest taking a look at our Apple Watch deals page. 

Roland Moore-Colyer

Roland Moore-Colyer a Managing Editor at Tom’s Guide with a focus on news, features and opinion articles. He often writes about gaming, phones, laptops and other bits of hardware; he’s also got an interest in cars. When not at his desk Roland can be found wandering around London, often with a look of curiosity on his face. 

Read more
apple watch 4
Apple Watch escapes U.S. import ban after court victory in patent case
The Apple Watch Series 10 on a user's wrist showing a colorful orange and pink home screen
Apple just lost the wearables crown to this major rival as Apple Watch shipments tumble by over 3 million
The Apple Watch Series 10 on display at the device's launch in September 2024
Apple Watch sales plummet 19% as smartwatch market declines for first time
The Apple Watch Series 10 on display at the device's launch in September 2024
Apple Watch 11 — all the rumors so far
Apple Watch 10 models shown at Apple event
Best Apple Watch deals in March 2025
Apple Watch SE 2022 showing the activity widget in watchOS 11
Apple Watch SE 3 — everything we know so far about the next-gen budget watch
Latest in Smartwatches
The Apple Watch Series 10 on display at the device's launch in September 2024
Apple Watch sales plummet 19% as smartwatch market declines for first time
apple watch 4
Apple Watch escapes U.S. import ban after court victory in patent case
Apple Watch Ultra 2 on a black silicone strap and Amazfit T-Rex 3 on an orange silicone strap shown side-by-side on a user's wrist
I walked 10,000 steps with Apple Watch Ultra 2 vs Amazfit T-Rex 3 —here's the winner
Close-up of the Amazfit Active 2 on a user's wrist with the maps display shown
I just tested the Amazfit Active 2 — 7 things you should know about my favorite smartwatch under $100
The Circular Ring 2, up close, with half of the device slightly obstructed by orange glass in the foreground
Circular Ring 2 is now available to pre-order — and you could save up to $310 right now
Close up of the Amazfit T-Rex 3 smartwatch on an orange silicone strap
I just went hands-on with the Amazfit T-Rex 3 and it could be my new favorite wallet-friendly rugged smartwatch
Latest in News
Sonos logo on a smart speaker
Sonos halts work on rumored super streaming device — what's next?
NYTimes Connections
NYT Connections today hints and answers — Thursday, March 13 (#641)
HomePod with display concept render
Apple HomePod with display now rumored for late 2025 launch
The Apple Watch Series 10 on display at the device's launch in September 2024
Apple Watch sales plummet 19% as smartwatch market declines for first time
Google's Project Astra working on prototype smartglasses in an advertisement
Google just acquired this eye tracking company — hinting at the return of Google glasses
iPhone 17 Air render
iPhone 17 Air could be just 5.5mm thick — but 9.5mm when you throw in the camera bump