Android 12 has a controversial change — and some people are really upset

android 12 developer preview
(Image credit: Shutterstock)

Android 12 has introduced a whole host of changes, but not all of them are popular among users. One of those is the change to the power menu — the menu that appears when you hold the power button — which is drastically different to its counterpart in Android 11.

The main complaint is the removal of the G Pay and Home device controls within the power menu itself. Now, it's just a three-button menu with Power Off, Reset, Emergency. The aforementioned controls were moved to Quick Settings.

android 12 beta 3 power menu

(Image credit: Tom's Guide)

Some users and outlets are saying the power menu is ruined, but even some Googlers have chimed in on the issue. Over on Google's issue tracker, someone raised this "problem" and a Googler responded:

"If this is intentional, our product is doomed."

android 11 power menu

Android 11's power menu (Image credit: Tom's Guide)

Talk about hyperbole. While saying the power menu is "ruined" is quite a stretch, I'm on the fence about this one. I don't mind the controls being moved to Quick Settings — especially since I've never used the G Pay controls in the power menu and just tap my phone to a reader — but I do miss easy access to Home device toggles, like my lights.

Take what you will from this. Perhaps it was change for change's sake, or maybe Google thought those controls were better suited for Quick Settings. If nothing else, I liked having them tucked away in the power menu to keep them out of sight unless I needed them. Like I said, though, I'm not hung up on this, but maybe I'm in the minority.

Android 12 is still in beta form, so it's possible that Google might reverse this change before the final release. There seem to be quite a few people upset by it, so who knows.

TOPICS
Jordan Palmer
Phones Editor

Jordan is the Phones Editor for Tom's Guide, covering all things phone-related. He's written about phones for over six years and plans to continue for a long while to come. He loves nothing more than relaxing in his home with a book, game, or his latest personal writing project. Jordan likes finding new things to dive into, from books and games to new mechanical keyboard switches and fun keycap sets. Outside of work, you can find him poring over open-source software and his studies.

Read more
Finding a song using Google Gemini on a Galaxy S25 Ultra
One UI 7 just fixed a massive problem on Samsung Galaxy phones
OnePlus 13
OnePlus is ditching this iconic feature — and there's serious backlash
android 16 logo on a samsung galaxy smartphone
Android 16 could come with this key navigation change — and another new volume slider
Google Pixel 4a vs. OnePlus Nord
Google’s battery update is reportedly tanking the Pixel 4a — here’s what we know
Android Auto refreshed UI example
Google Maps annoys drivers after latest Android Auto update
Gboard app logo on mobile phone resting on a keyboard
Google Gboard redesign has already angered users — and I can see why
Latest in Android Phones
The camera assembly on the Google Pixel 9
The latest Google Pixel update is breaking fingerprint scanners — but there may be a fix
Google Pixel 9a render
Google Pixel 9a will have to fix one crucial thing to hold off its low-cost rivals
Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge back
Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge price comes into focus with latest leak
Google Pixel 5 review
Google Pixel 10 lineup leaked in new renderings — here's what they look like
Galaxy Z Fold 6 shown in hand
Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 6 just got these major upgrades with One UI 7
Pixel 9a vs Pixel 8a
Google Pixel 9a vs. Pixel 8a: Biggest changes to expect
Latest in News
iOS 19 logo on an iPhone
5 biggest iOS 19 rumors — here’s how Apple could transform your iPhone
Sonos logo on a smart speaker
Sonos halts work on rumored super streaming device — what's next?
Google Gemini and a pair of robotic hands
Google is putting it's Gemini 2.0 AI into robots — here's how it's going
NYTimes Connections
NYT Connections today hints and answers — Thursday, March 13 (#641)
The cast of The Wizard of Oz
5 best kids' movies based on books to stream now
HomePod with display concept render
Apple HomePod with display now rumored for late 2025 launch