AirPods Max three months later — is it really worth $549?

AirPods Max review
(Image credit: Future)

The Apple AirPods Max launched about three months ago. Perhaps you ordered this pair of headphones the day it debuted, or perhaps you waited a little longer to get yours, since finding it in stock was no simple task for a while. 

Perhaps you still have some questions about how the AirPods Max holds up over time before making the $549 purchase. If that’s the case, hopefully I can provide some answers for you.

I’ve been using the AirPods Max almost every day since it launched, and while that should tell you I enjoy it enough, Apple has not made the best headphones money can buy. My feelings towards the AirPods Max have changed now that we’re past the fog of first impressions, so here’s what I like and dislike about Apple AirPods Max after three months.

AirPods Max noise cancellation is next-level

When I first reviewed the AirPods Max, I couldn’t fully experience the active noise cancellation (ANC) feature. A combination of winter weather and the pandemic kept me inside my fairly quiet apartment. I resorted to playing a phony city sounds loop through my speakers to test how well the headphones filtered out car traffic and passing pedestrians.

But a few weeks ago I finally flew on an airplane, where the AirPods Max managed to drown out the jet’s noisy engines and chatty passengers. I think I might’ve even gotten a few minutes of sleep. My AirPods Pro could never help me find the quiet I need to catch some zzz’s mid-flight. While I still wish the AirPods Max offered various levels of noise cancellation like the Bose 700, its one setting is as effective as the best noise-cancelling headphones get.

AirPods Max review

(Image credit: Future)

The microphone quality is the best of any AirPods model

I’ve owned a lot of wireless headphones throughout the years, and my consistent complaint among them all is the microphone quality. No matter how pricey the buds or headsets, I worry that whoever I’m speaking to can’t hear me clearly on the other end. I also dislike how I sound when I wear most wireless headphones to record audio or video.

That’s no longer the case, thanks to the AirPods Max. Whether I need to gather voice-over for a project, chime in during a team meeting or just make a friendly phone call, the microphone quality consistently impresses.

The cups fall out too easily

Swappable, magnetic earcups are a defining aesthetic feature of AirPods Max. The oval pillows of memory foam aren’t as pulpy as those of the Sony WH-1000XM4, but they create a spongy seal around my ears. That is, when they stay put. 

On my AirPods Max unit, the earcups have a tendency to detach when the headset is jostled around. I don’t have this issue when they’re stowed away in their case (which is still ugly, by the way) but even when I place them down my desk too forcefully, the pads fall out. I mean, it’s not like I’m Hulk smashing them off my head — the way the earcups eject is a little dramatic for my liking. 

AirPods Max review

(Image credit: Future)

AirPods Max shouldn’t cost $549

The earcups’ magnetic effectiveness is one of the several reasons AirPods Max shouldn’t cost $549. If you ask me what my favorite piece of tech is, it’s my $399 Apple Watch Series 6. For $150 less than AirPods Max, my Apple Watch is an advanced health device, communication center and more. It seems like a rip off to pay more for a device with just one main function.

$549 is a lot of money for a pair of headphones, even one from Apple. It’s not easy to look past, considering most of the best AirPods Max alternatives right now cost several hundred dollars less. I wish Apple found a way to offer its first AirPods-brand over-ear headphones at a less controversial price. 

If you have the dough to spend, the AirPods Max is a one-way ticket to listening luxury. But be sure to check out our guide to the best headphones deals for savings on all kinds of headsets and buds — yes, including the rare AirPods Max sale.

TOPICS
Kate Kozuch

Kate Kozuch is the managing editor of social and video at Tom’s Guide. She writes about smartwatches, TVs, audio devices, and some cooking appliances, too. Kate appears on Fox News to talk tech trends and runs the Tom's Guide TikTok account, which you should be following if you don't already. When she’s not filming tech videos, you can find her taking up a new sport, mastering the NYT Crossword or channeling her inner celebrity chef.

Read more
Bose QuietComfort headphones held up against a blue sky
Best AirPods Max alternatives: My top picks under $300 right now
The Apple AirPods Max vs the Sonos Ace
The best AirPods Max alternatives in 2025
the soundcore space one pro headphones; a photograph of a pair of black over-ear headphones with cushioned cups and a soft headband, photographed in front of a blue background
Soundcore Space One Pro review: A masterclass in how to shuck off a ‘budget’ stereotype
Sony WF-1000XM5
Best Apple AirPods alternatives: Top picks of 2025
1More Sonoflow Pro
I tested these budget noise cancelling headphones and they’re amazing for under $100
the soundcore space one pro headphones; a photograph of a pair of black over-ear headphones with cushioned cups and a soft headband, photographed in front of a blue background
I just tested these new headphones and I like them more than Bose QuietComfort Ultra — and they're $200 cheaper
Latest in Airpods
Meta Ray-Ban smart glasses next to AirPods Pro 2
New report says Apple is working on Meta-style smart glasses and AirPods with cameras
AirPods Pro 2 in hand
AirPods Pro 3 major upgrades just tipped by new Apple patent
AirPods Pro
Apple releases instructions for installing new AirPods firmware updates — here's how
AirPods Pro 2 in a person's hands in front of a MacBook
AirPods Pro 2 are cheaper than AirPods 4 right now — this is the lowest price ever for Prime Day
AirPods 4 on a table
Don't wait for Prime Day — here's 15 Apple deals I'd get now from Amazon, Best Buy and Walmart
AirPods Pro 2
Apple AirPods Pro 2 just granted FDA authorization for hearing aid use
Latest in News
Nintendo Switch 2
Nintendo Switch 2 tipster may have just leaked release month and launch plans
Disney Plus logo
Disney Plus upgrade just fixed one of my biggest problems with the home page
Tom Hiddleston as Robert Laing in "High Rise" now streaming on Netflix
5 best Netflix movies in March you haven't watched yet
iPhone 16 with Apple Intelligence logo for iOS 18.1
iOS 18.4: All the newest Apple Intelligence features coming to your iPhone
Maria Debska in "Just One Look" now streaming on Netflix
3 best Netflix shows in March you haven't watched yet
Split image featuring the Galaxy S25 Edge (left) and Galaxy S25 Ultra (right)
Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge just tipped for two Galaxy S25 Ultra-level features