Madden NFL 25 restored my love for the annual football franchise — but it may only be a short return

Madden NFL 25 is the best the series has been in years

Madden 25 screenshot - Ravens player with ball stiffarms Bengals defender
(Image: © EA Sports)

Tom's Guide Verdict

Madden NFL 25 offers several improvements that dedicated fans of the annual sports franchise have requested for years However, it doesn't measure up to the high bar set by College Football 25. Only passionate pro football fans should pick this over EA’s other football game.

Pros

  • +

    Improved on-field action

  • +

    Brand new commentators are refreshing

  • +

    Great soundtrack

Cons

  • -

    Ultimate Team microtransactions remain annoying

  • -

    Long load times

  • -

    Franchise mode still feels under-baked

Why you can trust Tom's Guide Our writers and editors spend hours analyzing and reviewing products, services, and apps to help find what's best for you. Find out more about how we test, analyze, and rate.

Madden 25 review: Specs

Platforms: PC, PlayStation 5 (reviewed), Xbox Series X and Series S, PlayStation 4, Xbox One
Price: $69
Release date: August 16, 2024
Genre: Sports

Madden has been the king of football for decades, but the crown has slipped in recent years, can Madden 25 NFL retake the throne?

It’s been 12 years since the 25th Anniversary edition of Madden released under the same Madden NFL 25 moniker, and we’re sure a snarky commentator is lying in wait to claim that Madden hasn’t improved since then. I would argue that Madden has improved tenfold in the last decade, but would also acknowledge that the franchise’s monopoly on digital football hasn’t necessarily been a good thing for players. However, with the release of the excellent College Football 25 earlier this summer, Madden finally has competition. College Football 25 is a joyous experience, and has enjoyed a richly-deserved enthusiastic reception from players. With this rival on the scene, it’s never been more important for Madden to avoid fumbling. 

For the last couple of years, the Madden series has been laden with game-breaking glitches and frustrating quality of life choices. Unfortunately, EA hasn’t really had to try with Madden. This year, it feels like EA Orlando has finally listened to the fans, providing genuine on-the-field upgrades and spending more time on the little details that make playing a game seamless.

After years of lackluster performance, does Madden NFL 25 finally right the ship? Read my full Madden 25 review to find out how it stacks up.

Madden 25 in game screenshot of player talents and stats

(Image credit: Future)

Madden 25: The Basics

  • What is it?  Madden NFL 25 is the latest entry in EA’s long-running NFL football franchise, not to be confused with the 25th anniversary edition released under the same name in 2013. The sports simulation game virtually recreates pro football action and lets you play as some of the best teams and players in the world. 
  • Who is it for? NFL football fans of course, but also players of sports and football video games in general.
  • What’s the price? The standard edition of Madden 25 costs $69. There is also a Deluxe Edition for $99.99 and an MVP Bundle for $139.99 which includes College Football 25. Each edition comes with a selection of additional digital content, mostly for Ultimate Team.
  • What other games has the developer made?  EA Orlando, formerly Tiburon, is best known for making previous Madden games and more recently College Football 25. They also made EA’s latest golf sim, EA Sports PGA Tour. 
  • What games is this similar to? It’s a continuation of the long-running Madden franchise and is now competing with College Football 25 and maybe Maximum Football.

On the field

Madden 25 screenshot taken in photo mode - Vikings player stretches out to catch ball trailed by Raider defender

(Image credit: Future)

I quickly noped out of Madden NFL 24 due to some absolutely ridiculous bugs. I played a game where Justin Jefferson, known for this circus catch, refused to catch any ball thrown his way for all four quarters. It was the glitch that finally broke my resolve to play. 

Fortunately, Madden NFL 25 has not presented the same issues (so far). If anything, gameplay has been a massive improvement with tweaks to a number of systems that the casual fan might not notice but regular Madden players will love. 

Player animations are smoother than ever. The stellar animation work in both Madden NFL 25 and College Football 25 suggests that EA Orlando has finally figured out the Frostbite engine. 

I still find Madden’s pre-snap play art to be somewhat cartoonish, but adjustments to systems like the pass-blocking assignments really open up how you direct the offense. The ability to assign pass protections like Half Slide Right or Left to the offensive line helps you pick up blitzes and forces you to diagnose defenses more.

The AI finally catches up with how real-life football teams actually play the sport. So far, run heavy teams actually try to use their running backs in both passing and the run game instead of swapping in random bottom of the depth chart guys for swing passes. Noticeably, archetypes actually play to form, where a scrambling QB is more likely to run first than a pocket passer who will just throw the ball away if they can’t find an open receiver, which is something that wasn’t always a given previously.

A shiny new toy

Madden 25 in game screenshot of main menu

(Image credit: Future)

On the whole, Madden NFL 25 significantly improves the overall presentation compared to last year’s edition. The UI is snappy and dare I say even fun? 

I found that loading outside of gameplay is atrocious though. There were times when I would tap into a menu and it took so long that I thought the game had frozen. 

There are two audio quality of life changes that make Madden NFL 25 lightyears ahead of recent iterations. First, the soundtrack is probably the best its been in some time with no songs that I would classify as distracting or irritating, like LG Malique’s “Winning” from Madden 24. I even added a few of the game’s tracks to my own personal playlist. 

Secondly, EA has refreshed the stale commentary duo of Brandon Gaudin and Charles Davis with two new commentary teams. The headlining Mike Tirico and Greg “Third leg” Olsen offer up a fairly relaxing vibe while Kate Scott and Brock Huard offer a more intense play-by-play. Both are welcome additions, and I hope they return for Madden NFL 26

Game day

In game screenshot from Madden 25 - play art

(Image credit: Future)

Ultimate Team exists, with the same criticisms as always. Do you want to spend more money on Madden? If so, MUT will encourage you to drain your pockets from the get go. That said, the new challenge mode is surprisingly fun and engrossing and will keep you in the mode longer than you might have imagined, especially since you don’t have to play against other people. Still, if you never liked MUT before now, that won’t keep you here.

Outside of Ultimate Team, Franchise mode is still disappointing. Playing as a coach or an owner remain separate options which is nice for people who just want to focus on the Xs and Os. However, I like having the ability to set absurd prices for hot dogs, but I do admit that I glaze over when it comes to contracts and other financial busywork.

Where Franchise mode is lacking, and always has, is the inability to just be a coordinator of the offense or defense. It’s a stark contrast to College Football 25 where you can start a coaching career as a DC or OC. Honestly, it's a feature that Madden desperately needs to add to Franchise mode, and it’s a shame to see it omitted once again. 

The new “storyline” feature, which is supposed to break up the action and add a personal touch to your footballing career, forced me to make such bizarre choices that I started ignoring it. For example, in a pre-season training camp, I was asked if there would be a position battle for defensive end between my homegrown 92 overall superstar and his 75-rated backup. Of course not, never in a million years would that be a battle. I said, "No," and lost 10 team morale points for my team. And this wasn't the only absurd question I was forced to answer either. Even more frustratingly, Superstar mode has been slowly invaded by Ultimate Team’s microtransactions, with cosmetic uniforms and streetball options still available at additional cost for your avatar. 

However, the core pro-career mode is still good and the mini-game laden scouting combine is a delight. Even better, performance quests beyond just passing or running for a ton of yards offer a pleasant high when the RPG-like little green numbers tick up.

Madden 25 verdict 

Madden 25 screenshot - Chiefs center points out defenders against Eagles

(Image credit: EA Sports)

EA Orlando has made a good Madden game, and that’s no small achievement after two or three years of iterations that I would describe as disappointing at best, outright bad at worst. Unfortunately, despite the improvements , I spent most of my time playing Madden NFL 25 wishing I was back in college. 

If you’re primarily an NFL fan, you’ll be pleased with on-field action compared to previous iterations. However, if you’re a football fan regardless of league, then Madden will disappoint. It lacks the pageantry of College Football 25, resulting in a more sterile feel. And surprisingly, even with a new commentary crew, it doesn’t celebrate the NFL’s rich history, something College Football 25 does with a great aplomb. 

However, Madden NFL 25 remains one of the franchise’s best efforts in years, and I’m hoping that having to face off against the prodigal son will finally get EA Orlando to substantially improve thier mainstay franchise in the years ahead. For now, Madden NFL 25 is merely a good football game, rather than a great one like its college-set sibling. 

Scott Younker
West Coast Reporter

Scott Younker is the West Coast Reporter at Tom’s Guide. He covers all the lastest tech news. He’s been involved in tech since 2011 at various outlets and is on an ongoing hunt to build the easiest to use home media system. When not writing about the latest devices, you are more than welcome to discuss board games or disc golf with him. 

Read more
Image from a Madden 25 sim of Super Bowl LIX featuring the Kansas City Chiefs and Philadelphia Eagles
I used Madden 25 to predict Super Bowl 25 — here’s the ridiculous result
Civilization VII screenshot
I've played every Civ game since the start — here's my verdict on Civilization VII after 60 hours
Monster Hunter Wilds
Monster Hunter Wilds review — there goes my social life
Best Games of 2024
13 best video games of 2024 — our favorites on PS5, Nintendo Switch, Xbox Series X and PC
Split Fiction screenshot
Split Fiction is the best co-op game I’ve played since It Takes Two — but some of the magic is lost
Using a bow in Avowed
Avowed is a trademark Obsidian RPG and the perfect distraction until Elder Scrolls VI
Latest in Gaming
Nintendo Switch 2 promo image
Nintendo Switch 2 patent hints at a major improvement — and it could be the reason for the mysterious “C” button
Horizon Forbidden West on PC
AI-powered PlayStation characters are being tested at Sony — what we know
NYTimes Connections
NYT Connections today hints and answers — Tuesday, March 11 (#639)
Xbox handheld
Xbox handheld reportedly arriving this year, new PC-like console in 2027
NYT Strands on a cellphone
NYT Strands today — hints, spangram and answers for game #373 (Tuesday, March 11 2025)
Animated image of Super Mario Wonder game with Toms Guide act fast logo
Epic Nintendo Switch sale is live from $4 — 21 Mario Day deals I'm shopping now
Latest in Reviews
MacBook Air 13-inch M4 shown on tabletop
Apple MacBook Air M4 review: the best gets (slightly) better and cheaper
The Fluance Ri71 in Tom's Guide's audio testing environment.
I just tested these epic powered speakers: Don't buy a $400 soundbar, buy these instead
Apple Mac Studio M4 Max review unit on a desk
Apple Mac Studio M4 Max review: More powerful than ever
iPad Air M3
Apple iPad Air M3 review: The sweet spot just got even sweeter
the black bose smart soundbar 2024 with remote, 2 touch controls on top, and mesh covering on top
I put this $500 Bose soundbar to the test — it’s a great smart home product, but it won’t impress movie fans
Nacon Revosim RS Pure
I just tested the Nacon Revosim RS Pure sim racing rig — it feels like Fanatec for a fraction of the price