I’ve been playing Overwatch since Day 1 — here’s why Overwatch Classic isn’t working

An Overwatch 2 promotional image featuring six of the games' main heroes
(Image credit: Blizzard Entertainment)

I've been playing Overwatch on and off since its launch, and over the past eight years, it has provided some of the most exhilarating moments in my gaming career. Few experiences compare to the thrill of landing a quad kill with D.Va’s self-destruct, re-meching, and single-handedly securing a point. That rush remains just as potent now as it was in 2016.

Throughout the years, the Overwatch community has experienced many shifts, from the unbridled excitement of the post-launch period to the drudgery of the enduring GOATs meta, followed by renewed hope at the announcement of Overwatch 2, and confusion when the ‘sequel’ launched. It’s been anything but a smooth ride for fans.

No matter how people feel about the current state of the game, one sentiment echoes among veteran players: it just doesn’t feel the same. With an ever-expanding roster, eight years of balance changes, new maps, and gameplay adjustments, Overwatch has evolved significantly. The solution to the community’s nostalgic longing seemed simple to me—an optional mode that restored the game to its original state. Now that Blizzard has introduced Overwatch Classic, I’ve realized I might have been wrong.

A promotional image for Overwatch Classic featuring a six character roster of heroes

(Image credit: Blizzard Entertainment)

Overwatch Classic is a limited-time mode that could become a permanent fixture, reverting the game to its 2016 launch state. The roster is limited to the original 21 heroes, team sizes return to 6v6, and hero abilities are mostly restored to their initial forms. For heroes with significant reworks, such as Cassidy, it can feel like playing an entirely different character.

It’s a surprisingly comprehensive recreation of the game’s early state and represents no small effort on the part of the developers. Overwatch 2 saw the game switch to a new engine, meaning it was no simple rollback of code—the conditions for even a facsimile of the original would have had to be meticulously crafted over months of development work.

One notable change in this mode is the removal of hero limits—teams can stack multiple instances of a single hero. Want two Roadhogs? Go for six! This leads to some amusing meme compositions; watching a turret-toting Torbjörn six-stack storm to victory is undeniably entertaining. However, it’s hardly conducive to cohesive gameplay.

This unrestricted chaos makes it difficult to find any real rhythm in matches, as players face constant interruptions and lineup changes. The tagline “relive the chaos” is apt—Overwatch Classic delivers on that front. Some fans have joked that this mode was created to remind players how far the game has come, and it’s hard to argue with that.

Blizzard’s long-standing reluctance to introduce such a mode stemmed from concerns about splitting the player base and siphoning players from standard quick play and competitive matches. If they wish to satisfy fans with a throwback experience, Blizzard needs to incorporate the fundamental improvements made over the years to maintain match flow and prevent total anarchy.

Perhaps this rollout is Blizzard’s elaborate way of thumbing their nose at fans who long for the “good old days.” Regardless, it’s clear that nostalgia alone isn’t enough to win back the hearts and minds of lapsed fans.

Jack Ridsdale
Sleep Deals Writer

Jack, a multimedia journalist, is the Sleep Deals Writer for Tom's Guide. Since attaining his journalism degree at the University of Gloucestershire, Jack has built up eight years of experience in writing and content creation. At Tom’s Guide, he is responsible for reporting on the latest deals and sales on mattresses, mattress toppers, beds, bedding, and sleep tech. Jack is fascinated by the link between sleep and mental health, productivity, and general quality-of-life. He’s especially interested in exploring how technology from brands like Sleep Number and Eight Sleep can improve sleep and general wellbeing. His other interests include live music and gaming, subjects about which he has penned thousands of words.

Read more
Elden Ring Nightreign
Elden Ring Nightreign could be this year’s best multiplayer game — but I’m still not sold
Civilization VII screenshot
I've played every Civ game since the start — here's my verdict on Civilization VII after 60 hours
Monster Hunter Wilds
I quit Monster Hunter World after a few hours — but Monster Hunter Wilds just became my early GOTY pick
A screenshot from Sniper Elite: Resistance showing the hero carrying a body while firing a pistol
Sniper Elite: Resistance offers more of the same stealth-action — here’s why that's a good thing
Caves of Qud screenshot
This is the best RPG I've played since Baldur's Gate 3 — here's why
Split Fiction screenshot
Split Fiction is the best co-op game I’ve played since It Takes Two — but some of the magic is lost
Latest in Gaming
Nintendo Switch 2
Nintendo Switch 2 — industry insider just tipped release month and launch plans
Wolfenstein: The Old Blood
Amazon is giving away a ton of free games for its Big Spring Sale — here’s how to claim yours
NYTimes Connections
NYT Connections today hints and answers — Tuesday, March 25 (#653)
Wordle answer for #1,244, Thursday, November 14
I used ChatGPT to help me win at Wordle — here's what happened
half-life alyx
Latest Half-Life 3 rumors point to a 2025 release — and maybe pigs will fly
NYT Strands on a cellphone
NYT Strands today — hints, spangram and answers for game #387 (Tuesday, March 25 2025)
Latest in Opinion
The Amazfit T-Rex 3 shown close-up on a user's wrist with the snorkeling and surfing workout tracking modes displayed; colorful flowers are out of focus in the background
7 reasons why this budget-friendly smartwatch is my new go-to for surfing and swimming
Apple maps logo on iPhone screen
I avoided Apple Maps for trip planning — but these iOS 18 features are changing my mind
Adam Scott in "Severance," now streaming on Apple TV Plus.
'Severance' season 3 officially greenlit — but I may not watch after that season 2 finale
Woman has taped her mouth shut with a blue I shaped mouth tape
I tried I-shaped mouth tape to fall asleep faster but now I'm more tired than ever — here's why
An angled view of the distraction-free desk setup I built around the Oakywood Standing Desk Pro
I built a completely distraction-free desk setup with these 10 gadgets — and now I’m truly locked in
A Samsung DU7200 LED TV on a side table
I'm a TV reviewer — here's the one type of TV I wouldn't buy