This romantic comedy movie just crashed the Netflix top 10 — and viewers seem to love it more than critics

Kimberly Elise and Shemar Moore in "Diary of a Mad Black Woman"
(Image credit: Lionsgate)

While popular action-thriller movies like "Rebel Ridge" and "Edge of Tomorrow" have dominated Netflix’s top 10 this week, an almost 20-year-old movie has somehow snuck into this list — and it has incredibly divided reviews. 

Currently sitting in the No.7 spot is "Diary of a Mad Black Woman" (as of September 10), a romantic comedy-drama that follows a woman who faces betrayal and divorce from her cheating husband. With support from her grandmother, she goes on a journey of self-discovery and empowerment. 

While critics have offered mixed opinions on the movie, audiences have rallied around it, giving it a much higher score and defending its appeal on Rotten Tomatoes. Even though it probably won’t be No.1 on the streaming service, there’s a chance it could rise through the ranks slowly the more people notice it. But is it worth watching? Here’s everything to know about "Diary of a Mad Black Woman"... 

What is 'Diary of a Mad Black Woman' about?

Tyler Perry's Diary of a Mad Black Woman - Trailer - YouTube Tyler Perry's Diary of a Mad Black Woman - Trailer - YouTube
Watch On

"Diary of a Mad Black Woman" is directed by Darren Grant and written by Tyler Perry. It's a romantic drama-comedy that follows Helen McCarter (Kimberly Elise), a devoted wife who discovers that her husband Charles (Steve Harris) is cheating on her and wants a divorce. 

After being abruptly thrown out of her home, Helen goes through a journey of self-discovery and healing with the help of her strong and supportive family, including her grandmother, Madea (played by Tyler Perry himself). Madea is a no-nonsense, wise and outspoken matriarch who provides both comic relief and sage advice throughout the movie.

'Diary of a Mad Black Woman' reviews — why are viewers split?

It seems as though viewers have very different opinions when it comes to "Diary of a Mad Black Woman". Critics gave this movie a low score of 16% while audiences rated it high at 86% on Rotten Tomatoes. Most of the criticism comes down to the exaggerated humor and uneven balance between comedy, romance and serious drama. 

Amy Biancolli from Houston Chronicle said: "The film itself is a touch insane, veering from comedy to cornball melodrama (and torture!) with such startling alacrity that viewers might laugh and not know if they're supposed to." Washington Post’s Michael O'Sullivan wasn’t a fan either: "To review Diary of a Mad Black Woman is really to review three different movies, none of which are very good."

However, there are some critics who enjoyed this romantic comedy. Ruthe Stein from San Francisco Chronicle stated that the movie is "raucous and overwrought, but it’s still a hoot to watch."

Steve Harris, Lisa Marcos and Kimberly Elise in "Diary of a Mad Black Woman"

(Image credit: Lionsgate)

And then there are the audience reviews, which are a lot more positive. Some said they "loved everything about it" while others agreed it "doesn’t deserve one star." The most common review of this movie is that while it’s very funny, it still tells a "surprisingly intriguing story."

Judging by the different critics and audience reviews, "Diary of a Mad Black Woman" is made for people with a very specific type of humor. Director Darren Grant knew this would have melodramatic elements, and so it’s ideal for anyone who seeks an entertaining watch that isn’t afraid to be silly at times.

Should you stream 'Diary of a Mad Black Woman'?

Kimberly Elise as Helen McCarter in "Diary of a Mad Black Woman"

(Image credit: Lionsgate)

With split reviews and mixed critical responses, "Diary of a Mad Black Woman" remains an interesting choice. However, if you enjoy romantic comedies with a strong dose of humor and emotional depth, this movie might resonate with you. It’s especially worth a watch for those who appreciate Tyler Perry’s distinctive storytelling and the charismatic presence of Madea. 

Not totally sold on it? Check out this action movie on Prime Video before it leaves the streamer. You can also see our guide on the best Netflix movies in 2024 if you’re looking for something to watch.  

Stream "Diary of a Mad Black Woman" on Netflix.

More from Tom's Guide

Alix Blackburn
Staff Writer, Streaming

Alix is a Streaming Writer at Tom’s Guide, which basically means watching the best movies and TV shows and then writing about them. Previously, she worked as a freelance writer for Screen Rant and Bough Digital, both of which sparked her interest in the entertainment industry. When she’s not writing about the latest movies and TV shows, she’s either playing horror video games on her PC or working on her first novel.

Read more
David Oyelowo as Detective Jack Radcliff in "Don't Let Go"
This new to Netflix mystery thriller just crashed the top 10 — and viewers disagree with critics
(L-R) Tobias Menzies as Don and Julia Louis-Dreyfus as Beth in "You Hurt My Feelings"
Netflix just got a delightful comedy-drama that's already crashed the top 10 — and it’s 94% on Rotten Tomatoes
Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni in It Ends With Us
'It Ends with Us' is the latest Netflix No. 1 movie — but this romantic drama is controversial
Kinda Pregnant movie with Amy Schumer
Netflix's newest No. 1 movie is being blasted by critics — watch these 3 comedy movies instead
Lt. Campbell (Milauna Jackson) and Major Charity Adams (Kerry Washington) (L-R) in "The Six Triple Eight"
Netflix just added a new war drama — and you need to ignore the critics
Keira Knightley in "Black Doves" on Netflix
Netflix’s new No. 1 show is one of my favorite thrillers of the year — and it’s 94% on Rotten Tomatoes
Latest in Netflix
Rachel Weisz as Marlee in "Runaway Jury"
Netflix top 10 movies — here’s the 3 worth watching right now
Tom Hiddleston as Robert Laing in "High Rise" now streaming on Netflix
Netflix just got one of the most overlooked sci-fi thrillers of the past decade — and it’s a mind-bending movie
A TV with the Netflix logo sits behind a hand holding a remote
5 new to Netflix movies with 90% or higher on Rotten Tomatoes
IU (Lee Ji-eun) in "When Life Gives You Tangerines" now streaming on Netflix
Netflix’s new romantic drama show is a truly heartwarming watch — and you can stream it now
"The Recruit" and "The Night Agent" in a composite image.
'The Night Agent' probably got 'The Recruit' canceled — here's why
Valerie Pachner as Esther on the set of Delicious
Netflix’s new dark thriller will keep you guessing until the very end — and it needs to be on your watchlist
Latest in News
Apple Intelligence logo on iPhone
Apple confirms Siri 2.0 is delayed — 'it’s going to take us longer than we thought'
NYTimes Connections
NYT Connections today hints and answers — Saturday, March 8 (#636)
MacBook Air M4 vs. MacBook Air M1
MacBook Air M4 vs MacBook Air M1: 7 biggest upgrades
Switch 2 and Mario
Nintendo Switch 2 FCC filing just revealed Wi-Fi 6 and NFC — but that's not all
iPhone 17 Pro render
iPhone 17 Pro Max and iPhone 17 Air designs just teased in new video — here's your first look
Harry Maguire of Manchester United in action during a Premier League match in February 2025
Man Utd vs Arsenal live stream: How to watch the Premier League game online