Marvel’s ‘Agatha All Along’ reviews are in — and critics and audiences don’t agree

Kathryn Hahn as Agatha Harkness in Marvel's Wandavision TV show
(Image credit: Marvel Entertainment)

"Agatha All Along" has been projected to be the biggest Marvel show coming to the MCU this year. A sequel/spin-off to the popular Disney Plus show "WandaVision," it brings Kathryn Hahn back to the MCU, reprising her role as the witch Agatha Harkness.

While Harkness was a fan favorite from "WandaVision," expectations for this limited series have been ... mixed. Some people were excited to see Hahn return, while others were a bit surprised that Marvel was committing to a TV show about such a minor character.

Well, the early reviews are in and — fittingly — they're mixed. Currently, the show holds a 69% "fresh" rating on Rotten Tomatoes. But just because critics aren't sold on a show doesn't mean audiences agree, and the early audience impressions indicate that critics might be a bit harsh on Marvel's latest show.

So should you stream "Agatha All Along" right now? Or is this MCU show a skip? Here's what you need to know.

What is 'Agatha All Along' about?

Marvel Television’s Agatha All Along | Official Trailer | Disney+ - YouTube Marvel Television’s Agatha All Along | Official Trailer | Disney+ - YouTube
Watch On

"Agatha All Along" picks up three years after "WandaVision." In the beginning of episode 1, we meet Agatha starring in a TV show called "Agnes of Westview," in which Agatha plays the fictional detective Agnes O'Connor. She's trying to solve a Jane Doe murder case when a detective, Vidal (Aubrey Plaza), shows up on the scene.

Except that detective is actually Rio Vidal, another witch who reveals that Agatha has been imprisoned this whole time by Wanda Maximoff aka The Scarlet Witch. It's at this point, that Agatha discovers she no longer possesses her mystical powers.

With the help of "Teen" (Joe Locke), Agatha escapes Wanda's spell. Now, they and their newly formed coven of witches (Debra Jo Rupp, Sasheer Zamata, Ali Ahn and Patti LuPone) must face the trials of the legendary Witches' Road so that Agatha can restore her powers. If they don't succeed, Agatha could face the wrath of the group of magic users known as Salem's Seven.

What are critics and audiences saying about 'Agatha All Along'?

Agatha (Kathryn Hahn), Joe Locke and other members of the "Agatha All Along" cast as seen in the trailer

(Image credit: Disney)

As previously mentioned, critics are a bit more sour on "Agatha All Along" than audiences. 

A lot of the more negative reviews declare the show "boring," "underwhelming" and "lackluster." The most brutal of these might be the review from Nick Schrager at The Daily Beast, who calls the show "a pleasant trifle that’s nothing more than a franchise footnote" and accuses Marvel of wasting talent.

And even the bad reviews often concede that the cast is talented. Christian Holub for Entertainment Weekly said, "Several of these actresses are delightful screen presences," even though they'd later go on to largely criticize the show for poor writing and character development.

But more of the reviews are positive than not. The most promising one I've seen so far comes from Belen Edwards at Mashable. They praise "Agatha All Along" for being "a Marvel show that's unafraid to be campy, kooky, and weird" and one that "embraces the episodic power of TV that WandaVision harnessed so well."

Audiences, meanwhile, are more positive on the show so far. Some still declare this Marvel show to be boring, but others echo Edwards's praises about the show's camp and nods to "WandaVision."

It's important to keep in mind that none of these reviews appear to be for the full nine-episode season, at least from what I've seen. Most are only for the show's first two episodes, which are all that's currently available on Disney Plus, though I did see one that claimed to have watched the show's first four episodes.

I'm not sold on 'Agatha All Along' after reading the reviews

Kathryn Hahn as Agatha Harkness in Marvel's Wandavision TV show

(Image credit: Marvel)

After sifting through the reviews for "Agatha All Along," I'm not sold yet. I'll freely admit a bit of bias — the show's trailers didn't particularly grab me and Marvel's recent MCU fare has me a bit gun-shy. 

But more importantly, these reviews are all largely for just the show's first two episodes. Much of the negative criticism could simply be down to an exposition-heavy pair of episodes that, admittedly, are perhaps not the most engaging.

So with seven episodes still to go, why not wait? Unless you're desperate to not be spoiled or a Marvel superfan, I can't see why waiting to see if the show picks up and garners more positive buzz as it approaches its mid-season point wouldn't be worth the wait. 

If you absolutely cannot wait though, make sure to check out our guide on how to watch 'Agatha All Along' online from anywhere. If you're not a Disney Plus subscriber yet, take advantage of this amazing $2 Disney Plus deal so you can watch "Agatha All Along," as well as many other shows and movies from Marvel, "Star Wars" and more.

More from Tom's Guide

TOPICS
Malcolm McMillan
Senior Streaming Writer

Malcolm McMillan is a senior writer for Tom's Guide, covering all the latest in streaming TV shows and movies. That means news, analysis, recommendations, reviews and more for just about anything you can watch, including sports! If it can be seen on a screen, he can write about it. Previously, Malcolm had been a staff writer for Tom's Guide for over a year, with a focus on artificial intelligence (AI), A/V tech and VR headsets.

Before writing for Tom's Guide, Malcolm worked as a fantasy football analyst writing for several sites and also had a brief stint working for Microsoft selling laptops, Xbox products and even the ill-fated Windows phone. He is passionate about video games and sports, though both cause him to yell at the TV frequently. He proudly sports many tattoos, including an Arsenal tattoo, in honor of the team that causes him to yell at the TV the most.

  • mikimous
    We saw this same skepticism with Wandavision. Not every Marvel project has to be Avengers level hype. It also seems premature to judge until the whole series has played.

    I actually enjoyed following Wandavision in real time...watching the episode that dropped that week...savoring the story point or frustratingly having to wait to continue the following week. I think watching it unspool in that way actually enhances the experience more.

    It's going to be something to look forward to weekly as we head into harvest season... So....let's see where it goes.
    Reply
  • marta.
    admin said:
    The reviews for Marvel's ‘’Agatha All Along’ are in after the first two episodes premiered on Disney Plus. Should you stream it or skip it?

    Marvel’s ‘Agatha All Along’ reviews are in — and critics and audiences don’t agree : Read more
    I think those critics need to take a clue because if the audience loves it then whats the issue but also did they see the show its clear from 10000 miles away marvel hasn't made any remotely that good since two phases ago
    Reply
  • THE TRUTHTELLER
    the only reason the critics are telling the truth is because the second season has already been cancelled, it is The Acolyte remade under a different name
    Reply
  • tommyhardware
    marta. said:
    I think those critics need to take a clue because if the audience loves it then whats the issue but also did they see the show its clear from 10000 miles away marvel hasn't made any remotely that good since two phases ago
    Loki season 1 and 2? Guardians of the Galaxy Vol 3? Spiderman No Way Home? Shang Chi? Wandavision? What If?
    Reply
  • tommyhardware
    THE TRUTHTELLER said:
    the only reason the critics are telling the truth is because the second season has already been cancelled, it is The Acolyte remade under a different name
    Huh? How is this anything like the Acolyte? Aside from Loki and What If, the Marvel Disney+ shows have been treated as mini series.
    Reply