Google continues to backpedal away from AI Overviews — could Reddit be to blame?

AI overviews
(Image credit: Google)

When Google rolled out AI Overviews in search results back in May, the company was hit with an immediate backlash; mostly due to some of the absurd results that the AI summaries were providing. These included telling people to add glue to pizza or claiming that adding more cooking oil to an oil fire would help put it out.

A week after its introduction, Google had already reduced the prevalence of AI Overviews from 27% of search results all the way down to 11%. 

A new report from Search Engine Land using data from the SEO firm BrightEdge (via Android Police), says that number has gotten even lower and Google has nearly eliminated contributions from sources like Reddit and Quora.

The feature was designed to utilize AI tools to provide summaries of information and help users find relevant information faster. 

According to the BrightEdge data, certain categories of queries like education, entertainment and e-commerce showed the biggest drop. As an example, entertainment searches dropped from 14% to 0%, while education queries reduced from 26% to 13%. Meaning, that only 13% of education searches will feature an AI overview.

E-commerce searches also saw a drop from 26% to 9% as well. That may partly be attributed to Google removing product viewers and carousels from AI Overviews as well as product comparison tables. 

The more relevant information for users is what triggers AI Overviews. Using phrases that start with "Best", "What is", "How to" and "Symptoms of" are more likely to trigger an overview. However, it appears searches that include a brand name, a general product or that relate to lifestyle content either don't seem to get AI Overviews or receive them less often.

It's unclear how much of the internet AI Overviews was scraping when Google launched the service, but it was clear  that it should never have been pulling from sources like Reddit or Quora, sites notoriously filled with troll-level answers to even the most earnest questions.

This means that fewer user-generated suggestions will appear; roughly 85.71% and 99.69% less for information from Reddit and Quora, respectively.

Additionally, the AI Overviews appear to be taking up 13% less real estate on search pages, BrightEdge's data claims. Google is also trying to prevent duplication of data by not citing the same sources in the AI Overviews as in the search results below it.

Google hasn't quite given up on AI Overviews, as the tool still exists and is active. It remains to be seen if it joins other actually useful programs in Google's product graveyard (RIP Podcasts app).

As reminder, you can try block of sorts on AI Overviews by changing settings in Google to give you a back-to-the-basics Search that gets rid of the frills of AI Overviews and some other Google-induced headaches.

More from Tom's Guide

TOPICS
Scott Younker
West Coast Reporter

Scott Younker is the West Coast Reporter at Tom’s Guide. He covers all the lastest tech news. He’s been involved in tech since 2011 at various outlets and is on an ongoing hunt to build the easiest to use home media system. When not writing about the latest devices, you are more than welcome to discuss board games or disc golf with him. 

Read more
Young woman shouting at her smartphone.
Google's AI overviews can be bypassed with this simple trick — but it's NSFW
ChatGPT on phone with Google logo in background
New study reveals people are ditching Google for AI tools like ChatGPT search — here's why
AI Mode of google search
Google launches 'AI Mode' for search — here's how to try it now
and image of the Google Chrome logo on a laptop
Annoying browser pop-ups could become a thing of the past thanks to Google’s new AI
Facebook logo on a phone display
Meta quickly deletes AI accounts and posts after intense backlash — what's going on
chatGPT search bar
ChatGPT Search is my favorite AI innovation of 2024 — and it's so good I've ditched Google
Latest in Search Engines
Google logo on the side of its HQ
Google is refusing to comply with upcoming EU fact-checking laws — what we know
Bing vs Google
Microsoft accused of making Bing look just like Google search — and Google fires back
Google search open on laptop
You can limit your Google searches to a single website — here's how
Chrome browser on phone with Chrome logo in the background
DOJ will reportedly force Google to sell Chrome — what you need to know
Google Shopping feeds on phones
Google gives Google Shopping an AI makeover — here's what's new
Google search on a phone screen
Google Search has a new trick up its sleeve — and it might save you from fake AI images
Latest in News
Apple Watch Series 10
Future Apple Watch models could get a surprising new feature — what we know
NYTimes Connections
NYT Connections today hints and answers — Monday, March 24 (#652)
NYT Strands on a cellphone
NYT Strands today — hints, spangram and answers for game #386 (Monday, March 24 2025)
iPhone 16 Pro vs iPhone 16 Pro Max in hand showing displays
Forget iPhone 17 — iPhone 18 could get this huge upgrade
The new Husqvarna iQ series robot lawn mower.
Husqvarna’s new robot mowers offer GPS for less
Rendered images of rumored foldable iPhone.
Foldable iPhone report just revealed key details — here's what we know