How do you test AI that’s getting smarter than us? A new group is creating ‘humanity’s toughest exam’

Adobe Firefly 3 image of robots taking an exam
(Image credit: Adobe Firefly 3/Future AI)

As AI gets smarter and smarter (including breaking rules to prove how capable it is), it's getting a little trickier to stump. Tests that work to push GPT-4o to its limits are proving easy for o1-preview — and it is only going to improve.

There's an understandable train of thought that AI could get too clever for humanity's own good, and while we're perhaps some way off of Skynet-level catastrophe, the thought has clearly crossed the minds of some technology experts.

A non-profit called The Center for AI Safety (or CAIS) has sent out a call for some of the trickiest questions for AI to answer. The idea is that these difficult questions will form "Humanity's Last Exam", a more difficult bar for AI to reach.

Every major AI lab and big tech company with an AI research division also has an AI safety board or equivalent. Many have also signed up for external oversight of new frontier models before release. Finding questions and challenges that properly test them is an important part of that safety picture.

OpenAI's new model breaks the rules to show how far AI has come

The submission form says "Together, we are collecting the hardest and broadest set of questions ever." It asks users to "think of something you know that would stump current artificial intelligence (AI) systems." Which could then be used better to evaluate the capabilities of AI systems in the years to come.

As per Reuters, existing models are struggling with many of the questions included already, and the answers between them are scattershot at best.  For example, the question "How many positive integer Coxeter-Conway friezes of type G2 are there?" has resulted in answers of 14, 1, or 3 from three different AI models.

OpenAI's o1 family of models, currently in a preview and mini version, have demonstrated an IQ of around 120 and solve PhD-level problems relatively easily. Other models are going to catch up; this is the 'lightest' o1 model' with better to come next year, so finding challenging problems is a high priority for the AI safety community. 

According to Dan Hendrycks , Director of the Center for AI Safety, the questions will be used to create a new AI benchmark to test new models. The authors of those questions will be co-authors of the benchmark. The deadline is November 1 and the best questions get part of a $500,000 prize fund.

More from Tom's Guide

Lloyd Coombes
Contributing writer

Lloyd Coombes is a freelance tech and fitness writer. He's an expert in all things Apple as well as in computer and gaming tech, with previous works published on TechRadar, Tom's Guide, Live Science and more. You'll find him regularly testing the latest MacBook or iPhone, but he spends most of his time writing about video games as Gaming Editor for the Daily Star. He also covers board games and virtual reality, just to round out the nerdy pursuits.

Read more
ChatGPT and Deepseek side by side on smartphones
I asked DeepSeek vs ChatGPT a series of ethical questions — and the results were shocking
Sam Altman
OpenAI takes aim at authors with a new AI model that's 'good at creative writing'
AI in man's hand
AI
ChatGPT logo on a smartphone screen being held outside
ChatGPT just got OpenAI's most powerful upgrade yet — meet 'Deep Research'
Perplexity and ChatGPT logos
I asked Perplexity for 7 prompts to challenge ChatGPT — here's what happened
ChatGPT logo on a smartphone screen being held outside
I put OpenAI's new o3-mini model to the test — and I'm shocked by the results
Latest in AI
A nervous woman looking at her phone
Is ChatGPT making us lonely? MIT/OpenAI study reveals possible link
AI in man's hand
AI
AI Madness faceoff logo
I just tested Grok vs. DeepSeek with 7 prompts — here's the winner
ChatGPT on iPhone
ChatGPT was down — updates on quick outage
Claude AI on phone sitting on keyboard
Claude 3.7 Sonnet now supports real-time web searching — but there's a catch
The Dnsys X1 Exoskeleton being worn
I tested an AI exoskeleton to help treat my immune arthritis — here’s what happened
Latest in News
Nintendo Switch 2
Nintendo Switch 2 tipster may have just leaked release month and launch plans
Disney Plus logo
Disney Plus upgrade just fixed one of my biggest problems with the home page
Tom Hiddleston as Robert Laing in "High Rise" now streaming on Netflix
5 best Netflix movies in March you haven't watched yet
iPhone 16 with Apple Intelligence logo for iOS 18.1
iOS 18.4: All the newest Apple Intelligence features coming to your iPhone
Maria Debska in "Just One Look" now streaming on Netflix
3 best Netflix shows in March you haven't watched yet
Split image featuring the Galaxy S25 Edge (left) and Galaxy S25 Ultra (right)
Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge just tipped for two Galaxy S25 Ultra-level features